Much as I’m loath to make an issue where none really exists (snort), if Friday the 13th isn’t a good day to talk about who’s wearing the goalie mask, whenever shall we do it?
Every traditional indication would have you believe that Matt Murray will be in goal for Game 1 when the Penguins start the Eastern Conference final tonight against the Tampa Bay Lightning at Consol Energy Center.
Murray exited the practice ice Thursday before the other goaltenders, a perk generally afforded the next game’s starter, and Marc-Andre Fleury said it was no secret that his 21-year-old understudy will start, while offering no theories on why neither coach Mike Sullivan nor general manager Jim Rutherford would say so.

It’s not so much an issue of relative aptitude when it comes to Penguins goalkeepers; it’s a timing issue, as I said.
If Sullivan and his staff are even considering putting Fleury back on the ice for the first time in six weeks, now is the time.
“I’ll probably announce it [today],” Sullivan said.
Read More
“That’s a question the coach has to answer,” Rutherford said. “He’ll make adjustments at the appropriate time. I think the situation has been handled extremely well.”
The situation, you may have heard, is that Fleury’s backups, Murray and Jeff Zatkoff, have carried this team to within four wins of the Stanley Cup final, but to get there you need every ounce of individual brilliance you can squeeze into a team effort.
Fleury with 100 percent of his gifts and experience is still better than Murray at 100 percent of his, never mind that Murray, in goal for the club’s past nine playoff games, has been just about brilliant.
“Speed?” Washington’s Alexander Ovechkin spat Thursday at a question about how his team lost to the Penguins in Round 2. “I thought it was their goaltender.”
But here’s the issue.
If one exists.
If Murray loses tonight or Monday night, or both nights, and a goaltender switch is required, it might plunge the Penguins into a new situation, one where they are trying to take the full measure of Fleury while a series is getting away from them. If they start Fleury tonight, or Monday at the latest, and they determine he is not entirely himself, they can pull him and still have time to recover in a seven-game series.
To be clear though, I’m not advocating for Fleury necessarily, only that there might be no better time for discovery on this issue.
If one exists.
“I’m not sure it’s different,” Sullivan said when asked if his goatender evaluations change with the so-called clean slate of being between series. “It’s not unlike any other position when we’re makin’ a lineup decision. We’re tryin’ to make the best lineup decisions that we think gives this team the best chance to win.
“When we have these discussions internally, that’s the first question I always ask. Then we discuss it. I think we’re very fortunate in that we have the options that we have.”
Rutherford spoke effusively on that topic from the perspective of someone with intimate knowledge of what it takes to put a Stanley Cup champion together.
“We have three good goalies, and I’ll start with Zatkoff — we might not have gotten out of the New York series if he hadn’t won that first game for us,” Rutherford said. “He played very well.
“The timing of Fleury’s injury was very tough. It was very tough to watch for all of us, and, for me, being close to it, because this is a guy who’s usually a pretty happy-go-lucky guy. He comes the rink everyday and he’s really happy. And there were a lot of days that you didn’t see that. That was really the toughest part of that.
“We knew we had a really good young goalie [Murray] coming. We knew that he would be ready to play. The plan was always, right out of training camp, that he would be part of the team by the trade deadline.”
Rutherford told me later that due to his full faith in Murray, he was not terribly worried about the Fleury injury beyond the emotions he had just described. He did not think the franchise goalie’s absence would necessarily impede his hockey club in the postseason, and that sentiment stemmed from his experience the previous time he had his mitts on the Cup.
In 2006, when he was running the Carolina Hurricanes, Rutherford watched head coach Peter Laviolette insert 21-year-old goalie Cam Ward for veteran Martin Gerber after Gerber had two shaky starts against Montreal in the first round. Gerber came back to shut out the Buffalo Sabres at a key point in the Eastern Conference final, but Ward essentially orchestrated the Cup run, winning 15 times and losing eight.
“Now remember, Gerber wasn’t a franchise goalie like Fleury,” Rutherford said. “A franchise goalie with plenty of good years left. Gerber was going to be a free agent.”
So sure, all of that makes this a tough call, and maybe no call is the right call.
But the timing certainly is tempting.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.