If it’s possible to gain control of an NHL playoff series by losing a hockey game, the Washington Capitals might well have done precisely that in Game 3 Monday night.

Nobody in the visiting locker room at Consol Energy Center on the day before Game 4 would say anything close to such a thing, of course, but the notion that the Capitals somehow turned these Eastern Conference semifinals inside out, even as they were getting strangled by the brilliant rookie goalie Matt Murray, did not exactly get laughed out of the room.

“Potentially,” allowed Washington defenseman Matt Niskanen, the former Penguin. “I know we don’t like the result [Monday] night, but I know we feel a lot better than we did after Game 2, so that’s important.

“We found out some things that are gonna work for us.”

Advertise with us

What is working and what is not in a series the Penguins lead two games to one are urgent tactical questions that are still getting buried by ugly spasms of bad behavior on both sides. A series many hoped would erect a monument to the speed and skill and scoring acumen of some of the elite hockey talents in the universe is instead another tedious peep show into what the league office thinks is “bad” and what it thinks is “late” and which informs its range of disciplinary reactions more consistently, the intent of some egregious act, or the injurious result.

“I don’t know if there’s an answer for that,” Niskanen went on. “Sometimes, I think yes [it should be based on the extent of the injury,] and, sometimes, I think the intent is enough, and it shouldn’t matter what happens. It’s kind of like guys getting high-sticked in the mouth. Some guys just take it, half their lip is hangin’ down, and they don’t go down, and other guys throw their gloves up in the air and lay down like they got shot in the leg.

“So, there’s no perfect answer.”

So Tuesday, two days after the league’s Department of Player Safety suspended Washington defenseman Brooks Orpik three games for a sickening head shot to Olli Maatta, the league gave Kris Letang, the Penguins’ most indispensable skater, one game to stew about his own sickening shoulder to the downturned face of Washington forward Marcus Johansson.

It could have been worse for Letang, who swung a stick at the neck of the New York Rangers Viktor Stalberg in Round 1, a sickening scene the league found neither bad nor late nor nothin’, which is what Letang drew as a penalty in that case. Nothin’.

Advertise with us

(Funny that the league, for purposes of discipline, defines “late” as six tenths of a second. Just like my father.)

Anyway, on the dubious premise that the Penguins and Capitals can show enough respect for each other to avoid turning this series into unremitting mayhem, it’s probably still worth discussing who has the better handle on it as Game 4 draws within hours.

“I think we took something positive from [Game 3],” said Capitals center Nicklas Backstrom, whose top line has held Sidney Crosby scoreless through almost 190 minutes. “I think we had a better game plan than the previous two games. We had a lot of shots.”

Washington outshot the Penguins, 49-23, in fact, and as for coach Mike Sullivan’s insistence that his team deploy the proven principles of puck management, well, let me put it like this: I’m no expert, but to manage the puck you might actually have to, you know, have the puck.

The Capitals kept the biscuit most of the night, and, even though they lost,3-2, they completed the first performance of this series by either team that could be said to be dramatically superior to its opponents’.

Advertise with us

“That was much more the game that we envision,” said Capitals coach Barry Trotz. “There are still some areas that we think we can get better at. We lost Game 3 last year against the [New York Islanders], but we sort of started to build our game. We were down in that series, 2-1 [and went on to win in seven], and, hopefully, there are some good memories of that we can carry forward. Going into the series, we talk about the things we have to do to establish our identity, and we didn’t go a very good job in the first two games. I think the last four periods, we’ve done a much better job.”

All of that established, if the Penguins win tonight, the Capitals will be forced to proceed with all the weight of their tortured playoff history seated resolutely upon their chests. They would have to win three in a row against a team that hasn’t lost two in a row in going on four months (Jan. 12 and 15).

If that suggests a must win for Washington in Game 4, then that’s what I’m suggesting. I wouldn’t want to be even six tenths of a second late with that.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.