WASHINGTON — If Penguins coach Mike Sullivan had any difficulty deciding whether to dress Olli Maatta for Game 2 after that rickety performance against the Capitals in Game 1, Brooks Orpik was only too willing to help him out.
Orpik drilled the unfortunate Penguins defenseman with a hellish elbow to the noggin just four minutes into the game Saturday night, drawing an interference penalty (he apparently interfered with Maatta’s head being on his shoulders), and sending Olli floating in a heavy fog to the Penguins bench, where he remained.
So much for that issue.
It was instantly all the more laughable that someone had actually asked Evgeni Malkin on the off day if it was fun playing against Orpik, his old teammate.
“No,” Malkin chuckled. “It’s no fun playing against Orpik. You’re always waiting for the big hit.”
Maatta didn’t wait long, but his exit ironically set the table for one of the greatest defensive performances in Penguins playoff history, delivering as it did a critical 2-1 victory that spun this Eastern Conference semifinal into a knot.
An almost predictable knot.
“It was tough, especially against a team that’s really good on the rush, but I think we did a great job,” said defenseman Kris Letang, who logged an incredible 35-plus minutes of ice time and led the Penguins in shots (6), hits (3), and blocked shots (5). “After the first period, we talked in the room about not turning the puck over in the neutral zone because on the back end we wanted to change quick.”
In that first period, the Penguins had held the Capitals to only five shots. They did it again in the second, five shots. And not even Washington’s 14 shots in the third were enough to get more than one past the brilliant rookie Matt Murray, who bounced back from his first playoff loss with a fairly astounding 60 minutes.
“I thought we did a really good job,” Murray said after stopping 23 of 24. “We did a great job blocking shots and clearing rebounds. There was a long stretch in the second period where I didn’t see a puck.”
For a team that had become known for its enviable ability to spread four or five or six goals across a typical night of hockey with some regularity, it was like something out of a magic act that the Penguins could pull this one out of their helmets on a night they went, like 0 for 26 on the power play in the second period.
It was actually 0 for 5 for the game, but it was clear they weren’t going to get this done with their universally well-regarded offense.
They were intent on accomplishing it with their puck management their defense and we might still be in Washington had it not been for Malkin, whose perfect centering pass found the stick of Eric Fehr in the Washington crease, where it hopped over the shoulder of Braden Holtby at 15:32 of the third period to break a 1-1 tie.
“Just goin’ to the net, tryin’ to redirect the puck, give it a chance,” said Fehr after scoring against his old teammates. “In the playoffs, you just gotta put pucks to the net. Crazy things happen. We would like to have gotten more out of the stretches where we dominated.”
But Washington’s 11th shot drew the Capitals even, never mind that the Penguins had 28 at that moment. Marcus Johansson, screening Murray at the cage, poked the puck across the goal line at 4:08 of the third period.
Nick Bonino, who set up the first Penguins goal from behind the net to Carl Hagelin, was in the middle of the defensive efforts as well, throwing himself to the ice to block a thunderous shot by John Carlson early in period three.
If Sullivan got some unwanted assistance from Orpik on a key defensive question, Washington coach Barry Trotz had no compunctions whatever on removing Dmitri Orlov from the lineup after his bumbling at the blue line permitted a Pittsburgh goal in Game 1. Trotz’s decision to go instead with former Penguin defenseman Taylor Chorney paid off nicely for him early in the second period when Chorney ran down Bryan Rust from behind and wrecked Rusty’s apparent breakaway, keeping Game 2 scoreless for the moment on a night when the Capitals were at one point getting outshot by 4 to 1. Not 4-1, no. I mean the Pens at one point had four times as many shots, 20-5.
Despite Pittsburgh’s defensive superiority, the most spectacular defensive plays — and hits — were delivered by the former Penguin defenders Orpik and Matt Niskanen. Niskanen flopped to the ice as Bonino led a 2 on 1 break with 10 minutes remaining, smoothing Pittsburgh’s best chance to retake the lead to that point.
But Fehr’s goal not only tied the series and flipped home ice advantage to the Penguins, it ensured that one of the all-time best defensive efforts was not in vain.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.