Given the requisite ditherings of your National Hockey League playoff schedulers, there was some level of concern Tuesday around the Penguins practice about rust, as Mike Sullivan’s team was to be idled for four days before conflagrating Thursday night with the Washington Capitals in Round 2.

Those Capitals, idle one day fewer, probably weren’t as concerned with rust as with Rust ... Bryan Rust.

That concern would be well-placed. No Penguins player posted a better plus/minus in the opening series against the New York Rangers than Rust’s plus-4, and no one shot the puck better than Rust, who hit 40 percent from the field, better than Pitt in the NCAAs, just for the record.

His two goals and an assist Saturday in Game 5 provided the fateful poison to the Penguins’ well-established spring nemesis, and for all of that, the prospect of Rust, 23, walking into the Shop’n Save on Rochester Road and creating anything close to a commotion remains pretty laughable, unless you would consider it a commotion if someone elbowed him and said, “Hey hun, can yinz grab me ’em pickles up ’ere?”

Advertise with us

“Not a lot of people are too familiar with my face yet,” Rust said Tuesday, laughing. “I’m good with that though. I’m kind of an independent guy. I kind of like my own space, privacy, all that.”

Well good luck with all that; I mean especially if Rust continues his Penguins rookie-of-the-year narrative as compellingly in these playoffs as he has thus far.

The fact is, Rust is a little at cross-purposes with himself on the matter of recognition, because he dearly would love to repeat the sensations he felt in Game 5, which included taking a centering pass from Evgeni Malkin and pumping it into the New York net at the emotional apex of a four-goal second period.

Is that what an 18-year-old thinks about when the Penguins take him in the third round of the draft, which is what happened to Rust five years ago?

“Well, I guess that was the dream,” he said. “To take a two-on-one pass from him or Sid in the playoffs and go in and score on Henrik Lundqvist. That’s something that I’m probably going to remember forever.

Advertise with us

“But hopefully, there’s more moments like that later in the playoffs.”

Rust isn’t the only one with additional dreams he would like to have fleshed out on the eve of the Eastern Conference semifinals. There are plenty of TV executives dreaming of a reprise of the great Sidney Crosby-Alexander Ovechkin showdown of 2009. Again at the peak of their powers, Sid and Ovie will by the laws of marketing dominate the marquees for this series, and it’s only natural. It was in that breathless playoff series seven years ago that hockey’s reigning superstars traded hat tricks in Game 2. It was in that series that they both scored eight times. It was in that series that the most highly discernible difference between them was so firmly established: Crosby used it to catapult his team to the only Stanley Cup of the Crosby-Malkin era, while Ovechkin’s team did not get out of the second round, and never has, and perhaps never will.

It’s almost ironic that here, seven itchy years later, the dynamics of this matchup are so much more than No. 87 vs. No. 8. It’s downright hazardous to the national story line. Not only are both teams so much deeper than that — 10 of the Penguins’ 12 forwards scored goals in the New York series, for example — but the decisive factor probably lies in a matchup nowhere close to the marquees.

It’s impossible to say what that matchup is, because both teams are thick with talent from one end of the bench to the other. Washington led the NHL with 120 points in the season just ended. No one else got 110. Forget that it took them three tries to eliminate the Philadelphia Flyers after bolting to a 3-0 series lead in Round 1. The Capitals are feeling this promising spring just as fully as the Penguins, looking for memories like the one Rust currently cherishes.

“The first one, that felt like no goal I’d ever scored,” Rust said of putting his team up, 3-2, in fateful second period. “You could just feel the crowd rise to it, and the feeling in the building got better and better from that point.

Advertise with us

“Hopefully, I can get a few more feelings like that.”

In four years at Notre Dame, Rust made a couple of those all-conference academic teams as a finance major. His dream then was maybe staying in hockey long enough to manage some team’s salary cap one day. Now he’s positioned himself to help define the hockey legacies of Crosby, Malkin and Ovechkin in what figures to be a delicious week or two of playoff hockey.

At some point, perhaps earlier than he would have anticipated, Rust might even have to come clean at a Shop’n Save.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.