The part of Cranberry Township where the Penguins practice appears to have been permanently separated from its pastoral history, but it wasn’t terribly long ago when you were more likely to see a barn or a chicken house than a Wendy’s or a Chipotle.

You never saw a Penguin, on skates or otherwise. Especially otherwise.

Today, inside the fabulous Lemieux Center for Undisclosed Injuries, the Penguins aren’t separated from a simpler time by very much at all. It was only a few weeks ago when Marc-Andre Fleury was the goaltender, Evgeni Malkin was carrying around the club’s most notable undisclosed injury, and Mike Sullivan’s team was on its way to winning 14 of its final 16 regular-season games.

But like the political lessons of urban sprawl, things can get pretty complicated pretty fast. Monday, Sullivan would not disclose the availability of any goaltender not named Jeff Zatkoff, and would not answer direct questions about potential line combinations, mostly because the number of potential moving parts on this team was best represented by the teaming traffic on Route 228.

Advertise with us

Sidney Crosby, the captain, was no help, not even on theoretical questions such as his preference (or the absence of same) for playing simultaneously with Malkin.

“I don’t pick the lines,” Crosby said. “I’m not going to start now.”

Game 3 of this pendulum playoff series with the New York Rangers is tonight in Manhattan, and it’s pivotal for plenty of reasons, two of which are conspicuously self-evident. One is that the Rangers have eliminated the Penguins from this tournament in successive springs and a Rangers victory tonight would put them halfway to a 3-peat, and two is that a Penguins loss is going to increase the focus on Malkin about 100 times, especially by the hockey fans who like to add 2-plus-2 and get 10.

“You’re talking about one of the best players in the world and he’s been so good here, and he was good on this team early in the year; it’s not that,” said Matt Cullen about the sudden appearance of Malkin in black-and-gold and the equally sudden halt to the Penguins’ momentum. “Maybe we allowed that to affect our game a little bit, because there was some juggling of the lines and moving around, so maybe the guys got a touch unsettled.

“But it doesn’t matter; it’s the playoffs. We can’t allow that to affect our game. If it did, shame on us.”

Advertise with us

Malkin had just centered a line at practice with Conor Sheary and Eric Fehr or Brian Rust, for what it’s worth, but with a player such as Malkin, it’s not so much who but how.

Malkin needs to very nearly dominate the puck to be a man in full on the ice, and if that requires him to east-west it in repeated loops through the neutral zone and points beyond, it can’t help but alter the tempo so-well established in his absence by a club with a neo-north-south mantra.

“We played a lot more of an east-west game [in Game 2],” Sullivan admitted, though not in response to any Malkin question.

I put it to Cullen, the most experienced player in the room, if either the notion of Malkin going in one direction while the Penguins want to go in another, or the prospect of too many Penguins getting hypnotized by the pathways of No. 71, deserved any credence.

“He plays a really unique style because his skill set is so unique,” said Cullen, still a spry 39. “A guy like that knows how to play the game better than most people in the world. He knows how to find his game within the system. It’s asking a lot for guy who hasn’t been out there in a month, when they’re on him, they’re keying on him, and it’s hard to get into the game, let alone a playoff game in that situation.

Advertise with us

“But he’s going to make a big difference for us.”

I think he’s right, but due to some uncomfortable math, it’s sounding like mostly an article of faith right now. With Malkin out of the lineup, the Penguins went 18-6-1 this season. They went 30-20-7 with him in it. In the 16 games after Malkin was injured March 11 at Columbus, including Game 1 of the Rangers series, the Penguins averaged 4.31 goals per game. In the 16 before Malkin was hurt, they averaged 3.18 goals per game.

But again, 2 and 2 do not equal 10.

In Malkin’s first game back, for example, the Penguins were playing with the third-string goalie, and they weren’t playing their best in front of him, much less at the far end.

“They didn’t do anything special; I think we didn’t do enough,” said forward Patric Hornqvist, who had a hat trick in Game 1 but was kept off the score sheet in Game 2. “We didn’t get the puck deep enough. We were always only one player on the puck. You have to have two and maybe three guys around the puck. That’s a thing we can control, so it’s a good thing. They did a great job, but the bigger part was that we didn’t.”

Advertise with us

There were plenty of reasons for that not named Evgeni Malkin obviously, but if you want to point out that the Penguins’ all-time record without Malkin is 84-47-9, that’s your prerogative.

Without Crosby, they’re 94-49-18.

Don’t even ask.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.