The Stanley Cup playoffs always arrive laced with uncertainty, especially the portion almost annually contested by the Penguins and the New York Rangers, so anyone pretending to know what will shake down over the next two weeks is engaged in pure sophistry.
The Rangers eliminated the Penguins in seven games two years ago, eliminated them in five games in 2015, and the only thing anyone should be allowed to say with reasonable certainty is that New York isn’t likely to eliminate the local hockey club in three this time around.
The palpable difference for this first round, the one that begins along Fifth Avenue tonight, is twofold, it says here. One is that, unlike April 2015, the Penguins will enjoy the availability of uber defenseman Kris Letang, currently playing at the absolute height of his hockey brilliance, but the other is equally foreshadowing in terms of being potentially decisive — Carl Hagelin was with the Rangers last spring; now he is with the Penguins.
And that is Yuuuge! As certain of your New York big mouths like to say.
“I’m not gonna sit here and talk about their team,” Hagelin said Tuesday after practice at the Lemieux Center For Undisclosed Injuries. “I think we have to focus on what we can do. We know they’re a good team. They’ve showed it year in and year out. We’ve gotta make sure we’re bringing everything we can.”
As long as they’re bringing Carl Hagelin, I like their chances because there wasn’t a better player on the ice in the previous postseason series between these two, and maybe not in the one before that. In 12 postseason games against the Penguins, Ranger Hagelin got four goals, two assists, and when it looked like the Penguins might claw its way back to life a year ago, it was Hagelin who popped home the series-winner in overtime of Game 5.
Read More
Subtract that quality from the blue shirts and inject it into Mike Sullivan’s lineup and you have a potentially fateful inversion. The difference Hagelin can make has been evident pretty much from the moment general manager Jimmy Rutherford pried him away from California Duckdom for the ridiculously low price of David (“and the Penguins are offsides”) Perron and defenseman Adam Clendening.
“The last eight games in Anaheim, I started playing the way I can,” Hagelin told me. “Then I got traded here, and I got the opportunity to play with good players right away, and I was feeling confident about my game. It worked out, right away, so I felt like a big part of the team, and after that, it was easy to get going.
“There were a lot of good players, so you just gotta make sure you’re doin’ your job, because you know they’re gonna do theirs.”
What Hagelin did after arriving in Pittsburgh in the third week of January is almost impossible to overstate. His six game-winning goals are the most by a Penguins mid-season acquisition, his always superb work as a penalty-killer solidified Sullivan’s PK into one of the league’s best, and as the season built toward a 14-wins-in-the-last-16 games climax, it was Hagelin as much as anyone who unlocked the true potential of linemate Phil Kessel, who scored 12 points in the final nine games.
And thus Kessel, too, becomes a pressure point in Penguins-Rangers politics that didn’t exist a year ago.
“There are a lot of new players, new coaches, new personnel everywhere,” Hagelin said about the new dynamic. “We all know that the playoffs are a different animal, but we’re definitely going in with the sense that we can beat any team on any night.”
That’s a pretty standard claim in any NHL April, and for every ounce of swagger the Penguins bring to the ice tonight, the Rangers will match it when the puck drops, never mind they’ll probably be missing their best player, defenseman Ryan McDonagh.
Deliciously enough, that’s what makes hockey’s playoffs the best tournament in sports. Few would be surprised if the Rangers got swept. Not much more than a few should be surprised if the Penguins got swept.
Rangers goaltender Henrik Lundqvist can skunk these Penguins, as he did Feb. 10 at Consol Energy Center, turning away 34 shots in a 3-0 shutout. And Lundqvist can be chased to the bench by these Penguins, as they did March 2. Similarly, Marc-Andre Fleury, concussion permitting, can shut down New York, and he can crumple in the postseason just as well.
No one can foretell these things; it’s up to no one but the people on the ice.
“We have players who have pretty good hockey IQs,” said Sullivan. “That’s one of their strengths. They like to play with the puck; they see the ice very well; they process the game really well. They’re the ones who get it done. Does that have an influence on how we coach them? Sure it does. Do we give some guys more latitude? Sure we do.”
The Penguins have done very well by giving No. 62 some of that latitude.
I have no idea who’ll win this series, but of this I’m dead certain: Carl Hagelin is one fine hockey player, especially come springtime.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.