Took me a couple of days, but I think I’ve figured out why those helmets pitchers are experimenting with in spring training this year leave the top of their heads exposed, as would a visor.
I guess if you’re a big-league pitcher who would let a pop-up fall on top of your head, no amount of protection is likely to preserve your career anyway.
Is that it?
For an industry that does everything but roll its overvalued pitchers in bubble wrap just to get them down to breakfast, it’s amazing how long the game has been indifferent to keeping their heads in one piece. Now, finally, Major League Baseball and its players union, in conjunction with a company named Boombang, has developed a …
Wait, Boombang?
That’s your name for a protective helmet? Funny, I’ve been developing a back scratcher but can’t think of a name for it; how about Bloodrake? No? Fleshripper?
The notion that pitchers should wear protective helmets always has gotten good reception in this space, but given baseball’s glacial movements on just about everything, even perfectly reasonable changes can be reasonably expected to take a decade or three to implement.
A pitched ball killed Ray Chapman in the batters box in 1920, but it wasn’t until Pirates general manager Branch Rickey mandated it in 1953 that the Pirates wore protective batting helmets. It took another 30 years before batting helmets had to have ear flaps.
Far more batters are hit with pitched balls than are pitchers by batted balls, certainly, but that’s not a reason pitchers needn’t or shouldn’t wear helmets. A handful of big-league pitchers take a liner off the noggin every summer. Some are concussed, some are knocked cold, some leave on stretchers, and somehow, thankfully, most recover.
Until, of course, somebody doesn’t.
Horror seems to be the only thing that speeds up the process, and even catastrophe is no guarantor of success. Poor Mike Coolbaugh, coaching first base in a minor league game in 2007, took a liner off the neck, suffering a collapsed artery, and died within hours. A helmet probably would not have saved him, but before the following season started, MLB required all of its base coaches to wear helmets.
Nine years later, the game sits at a point in its fits-and-starts history where those coaches, who are 90 feet or more from the plate, are required to wear helmets, where ball girls (or boys), who are approximately 200 feet from the plate, also are required to wear helmets, but where pitchers, who finish their deliveries within 60 feet of the plate, wear essentially the same headgear as when the first pitch was thrown by the first pitcher in the first game ever.
A piece of cloth.
But there is no mandate, and there is no rush to get one, mostly because pitchers don’t seem terribly interested.
Pirates relievers Mark Melancon and Jared Hughes, you might have read this week, plan to use them in the spring, but as Melancon told the PG’s Bill Brink in Bradenton, Fla., when the season starts “maybe coming into the ninth [inning], I don’t know if that would be good.”
That’s the vanity hurdle, and it’s no small thing.
Even in the NFL, a profession 100 times more violent and dangerous than baseball, players have declined to wear helmets that offer superior protection to the ones they wear now because they don’t like the way they look.
If that sounds stupid, that’s only because it is, but as Mike Tomlin would tell you, vanity is vanity.
Vanity kills people every day.
Everyone knows that car crashes are the leading cause of fatal head trauma, but do you see any drivers wearing helmets? The total number of people not currently driving race cars professionally but who are wearing helmets in their cars is pretty much stuck at zero.
Even though that would make perfect sense, you definitely would look uncool, and worse, you probably would cause fatal accidents involving other drivers who, seconds earlier, had been pointing at you and laughing.
As to the pitchers, one of their primary weapons, now and forever, is intimidation, and most would tell you that it’s hard to be intimidating in a helmet that makes you look like the Great Gazoo (awesome Flintstones reference — Google it).
Pitchers likely will tell you that their concentration is such that it can’t be disrupted by a foreign object on their head, that their delivery is calibrated to the millimeter on every twitch of every muscle fiber, that their extravagantly refined mound rhythms are not to be altered in any way, real or imagined — especially imagined.
And then they’ll give you 100 more reasons why they needn’t wear a helmet and shouldn’t be required to wear a helmet.
And then they’ll give you the next 100 reasons.
They just can’t give you a good one.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.