On Friday, April 1, 2011 at Wrigley Field, on the glorious undeclared holiday known as opening day, Neil Walker mashed a 3-2 pitch from Chicago Cubs starter Ryan Dempster for a winning grand slam, and thus a grand baseball narrative sprang fully formed into the game’s always improbable history.
It was the first opening day slam for the Pirates in almost half a century — since 1962 — when Roberto Walker Clemente cranked one against Philadelphia. The irony wasn’t right there in the middle of Clemente’s full name, however, it was in that Neil Walker’s father, Tom, was a winter ball teammate of Clemente at the time of the Great One’s death mission.
Tom wanted to join Clemente aboard his doomed plane on that final day of 1972, but Clemente talked him out of it, with instructions to enjoy New Year’s Eve in San Juan. Thirteen years later, the fourth of Tom’s children was born in Pittsburgh, and 19 years after that, Neil became the Pirates’ first pick in the 2004 draft.
After an arduous climb through a struggling organization’s barren minor league system, Neil’s first full season in the big leagues started with that grand slam.
It’s not likely any of that is new to anybody who would read this, but I’m pointing it out to illustrate that that trade Wednesday that sent Neil Walker to the New York Mets for a starting pitcher Jon Niese is more than just dubious on its baseball merits.
Though Walker and the Pirates are to some degree culpable for the difficult economic politics necessitating it, this is a trade that rips the fabric of the region’s relationship with its baseball team.
Read More
Though it’s very early in another dreary offseason, it says here the Pirates will be taking a step backward because of this — in wins, in attendance, and in TV ratings.
They became significantly less interesting when they decided last week to let Pedro Alvarez become a free agent and more so with the subtraction of Walker from an offense that’s suddenly down a combined 43 homers and 148 RBIs.
Walker was not a great player, just a good player, but he was so much more than the sum of his metrics, advanced or otherwise. He was the most visible contemporary component of the region’s sports heritage, galloping across WPIAL football fields in the bedrock Western Pennsylvania tradition, turning up in the Post-Gazette’s enduringly fabulous Fabulous 22.
That he would one day draw comparisons with Bill Mazeroski seemed like the plot of one of those fresh and juvenile baseball novels that once filled so many boyhoods.
His 23 homers in 2014 were the most for a Pirates second baseman, breaking Maz’s record of 19. He was the first Pirates second baseman to hit at least 10 homers in six consecutive seasons, and, while that might amount only to quaint and even arcane Pirates history, his tangible impact on the resurgence of the franchise after Generation Lost was monstrously evident.
This past summer, with the Pirates on their way to the postseason for a third consecutive year, they went 84-51 when Walker started at second, 14-13 when anyone else did. Neil led all National League second baseman in extra-base hits (50), homers (16), and slugging percentage (.427), and his 69 homers since 2012 are the most by an NL second baseman in that span.
Ultimately, that sounds exactly like someone the Pirates can’t afford, which is always the way, right?
Likely to make $10 million for 2016 after a final round of arbitration and, with typical production, maybe $40 million to $45 million on a three-year deal beginning in 2017, Walker is beyond the Pirates’ always timid reach.
Negotiations on a long-term solution began and pretty much ended long ago. Walker knew what kind of cash would be available at some point once Robinson Cano started raking $24 million per summer on a free-agent deal with the Seattle Mariners. Cano is the only other second baseman with 10 homers in six consecutive seasons. Similarly, Pirates general manager Neal Huntington knew what wasn’t available under the doggedly conservative ownership of Bob Nutting.
Just as there was no evident hometown discount, there was clearly no hometown bonus, and now the audience is supposed to feign enthusiasm over the acquisition of an undistinguished back-of-the-rotation left-handed pitcher. Good luck peddling that on the caravan.
On the upside, some other millionaire will get to soak up all that Allegheny Heath Network advertising dough. So there’s that.
But, yeah, around here, baseball always stinks in December.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.