Maybe it’s because baseball can appear so soft at times, a sport where a player is but a baby step from the disabled list when he gets shampoo in his eyes, where guys miss multiple games because they “slept on it funny,” where others get a day off if their biorhythmical data is trending downward.
Maybe that’s why a sport with the galaxy-sized comfort zone gets so comically animated about displaying its few harder edges.
Maybe that’s why breaking up the double play always has been a validating test of the game’s machismo, a frequent flashpoint that exposes a baserunner’s willingness to do his duty.
Even though he might not be willing to do something as dutiful as running out a grounder, or knowing how many outs there are, to break up a double play he will slide out of the baseline, slide late, slide hard, slide with malice aforethought, come in high, come with menace, any and all consequences be damned.
That’s baseball, is how we put it.
Except now, people are starting to get their legs broken.
Read More
And that’s football.
I don’t want baseball to be football.
When Chris Coghlan of the Chicago Cubs slid hard into celebrated Pirates rookie Jung Ho Kang Sept. 17, I thought, “that’s baseball.”
Coghlan was a little late and a little high, but he met Kang as the shortstop came across the bag toward him. Seen it a million times.
There was near unanimous agreement with that sentiment among the Pirates and Cubs, including Kang, but it was not universal, as Coghlan would later mention getting “a bunch of death threats.”
Then, Kang’s diagnosis came back. A displaced lateral tibial plateau fracture and a torn meniscus.
“Wait,” I thought. “That’s football.”
But there was no such confusion, at least there shouldn’t have been, when Chase Utley crashed into New York Mets shortstop Ruben Tejada in Game 2 of their National League Division Series.
“That’s football,” I thought.
Utley was way late, way on the other side of the bag, and way wrong. That was more like a block or a tackle than it was a slide.
Tejada’s diagnosis: Fractured right fibula.
See? Football.
Baseball suspended Utley for two games, but unable to enforce it without a hearing it couldn’t schedule with the players union until Monday, will watch and hope and pray that Utley doesn’t win the series tonight with a homer.
That would be special, right?
Pirates manager Clint Hurdle, speaking after the Kang injury, said he thought these kinds of plays deserved serious discussion, and in the name of player safety, he’s right.
But new rules? Spare me.
As in so many other instances, baseball does not have a rules problem; it has an enforcement problem. Remember the pine-tar rule, the glove-size rule, the coaching-box rule, the pace-of-game rules?
Anybody?
Don’t even start about the strike zone.
Here’s a rule covering the topic at hand, a rule I didn’t even know existed because I’ve never seen it enforced, at least not in the first 55 years that I’ve been paying pretty strict attention.
It’s part of Rule 7 covering interference.
Rule 7.09 (interference is called and the baserunner is out) when a baserunner willfully and deliberately interferes with a ball or fielder with obvious intent to break up a double play; the batter is also out.
Ex-squeeze me?
If it’s obvious, in the judgment of the umpire, that the runner is trying to break up a double play, the runner is out and the batter is out? In other words, you can cause a double play by trying to break up a double play?
Honest to God.
There’s a video on the web of then-Giants thumper Pablo Sandoval sliding into second and pulling Cincinnati Reds shortstop Zack Cozart to the ground with his outstretched right hand.
Wait, that’s football.
So then-Reds manager Dusty Baker argues with the umpires, who, after conferencing, signal a double play.
Amazing.
The same situation is covered in Rule 5.09 (a)(13), which includes this comment: “The objective of this rule is to penalize the offensive team for deliberate, unwarranted, unsportsmanlike action by the runner in leaving the baseline for the obvious purpose of crashing the pivot man on a double play, rather than trying to reach the base. Obviously this is an umpire’s judgment play.”
It was this rule baseball disciplinarian Joe Torre cited in suspending Utley. The umpires, who’ve traditionally enforced certain, uh, protocols let’s call them — you should slide in a manner so that you can touch the bag with some part of yourself, and you should slide before reaching the bag — don’t enforce the actual rules that would prevent these situations and render the protocols moot.
While we wait for that to change, I would suggest all middle infielders dig out some 1970s and 1980s vintage video on three-time Gold Glove second baseman Manny Trillo, whose scorching sidearm relay throws from the bag were rarely released above his navel.
Not a lot of macho men slid into a relay throw that would be coming at their foreheads.
That, too, was baseball.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.