This column isn’t stupid enough to second-guess the astronomical umpires at the International Earth Rotation and Reference Systems Service, but the decision by that agency to stretch Tuesday by one second — a leap second, if you will — commands some of our famously unscientific scrutiny.

For one thing, if we’re going to get an extra second, why can’t it be added to a Friday night?

An extra second of Tuesday is strictly punitive. It’s mean-spirited.

For another, if you’re going to cite a gradual slowing of the earth’s rotation as the impetus for putting a second back on the clock, you should at least name the thing that is causing a gradual slowing of the earth’s rotation, which, as we all know, is replay in baseball.

Advertise with us

There’s no doubt in my mind that this is how we got the extra second Tuesday.

Two scientists chomping Cheetos in the break room down at International Earth Rotation (Spin City, the insiders call it) were watching the Pirates last week when the umpires were again trying to decide whether Gregory Polanco had safely stolen second base. They watched as the umpire suspected of malfeasance and the umpiring crew chief, standing there like his dad, were outfitted with headsets by a technician. They watched as those umpires listened to other umpires in New York, who were watching the play in dispute. They watched as the umpires fidgeted while the New York umpires stared interminably at one of those little colored circles that indicate the video you’re trying to watch might or might not commence before next Tuesday. They watched and they watched until one turned to the other and said, “Hey, is it me, or are you feeling a gradual slowing in the rotation of the earth?”

“Totally; ya know, we should check that,” said the other.

And bang — leap second.

Noted social commentator Keith Olbermann recently suggested that the damage to a night of baseball theater brought on by these replay delays is so acute that, to compensate, a player should be selected at random to wrestle a small bear while the umpires “get it right,” but I would be good with a large bear.

Advertise with us

The time being stolen by baseball’s replay reviews is not only annoying to the people in the ballpark who happened to have looked up from their phones and actually seen the play in question, it’s absolutely punishing to home viewers who are then bombarded with replays from four different angles at three different speeds, plus three or four or five minutes of additional commentary, all highly speculative and nakedly partisan.

Somehow this system is thought to be superior to the one where the ump screams, “Out!” and it’s all over, except perhaps for a highly entertaining rhubarb.

Which would you rather see, seriously, in your spleen of spleens, a red-faced Clint Hurdle, his carotid arteries standing out like bridge cables, springing from the dugout and getting right into the grill of Joe West for a spirited exchange of views and spittle that ends with objects thrown and/or kicked and/or pulverized. Or, two guys in headsets standing near the box seats who look like they’re awaiting their blood sugar readings?

Agitation with this situation hit its crest recently when Chicago Cubs manager Joe Maddon went so far as to suggest umpires don’t know how to view video.

Wait, is it complicated?

Advertise with us

“I think it screams for an independent group back there [in New York] to research the video,” Maddon said after Cubs outfielder Chris Denorfia got thrown out at second to end a game against the Los Angeles Dodgers. “That’s what I think it screams for as opposed to working umpires that are actually on the field. I think you should get a bunch of nerds back there that know how to look at a videotape and then come to a conclusion. I think it would be much more interesting that way.”

Well yes, what this situation needs is obviously an independent research group that would add only about a week to 10 days to each dispute. If Maddon is saying that somebody other than umpires should be reviewing umpires, that’s certainly worth discussing, but if he’s saying that it takes a nerd with some kind of specialized visual capacity (maybe like Jeff Goldblum in “The Fly”) to know safe from out in slow motion, that’s just as certainly claptrap.

What he didn’t say was that Denofria should have been called out just for attempting to stretch a single into a double with his team trailing by three runs in the ninth inning.

But that would be baseball talk, and we can’t have that.

Instead we’ve got video of men standing around listening to men sitting around watching men who may or may not have just done something so they can inform the people who probably weren’t watching because they were looking at their phones.

Advertise with us

If you didn’t know, in the All-Star Game, the playoffs and the World Series, managers are permitted more replay challenges than in regular-season games. So, as I said, I think we’re gonna need a bigger bear.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.