A.J. Hines sat in his living room in Wilson, N.C., where his parents had to tell him it simply wasn’t going to happen. Not right then. Despite his best efforts, his standardized test scores were close but not quite high enough for admission to the University of Richmond, where he had signed to play college football.

Hines went in his room and cried, not knowing that six months later he’d end up leading all Football Championship Subdivision freshmen in rushing at Duquesne.

Sam Benger had kicked the tires at some small schools near home in Hingham, Mass., and mulled over a few preferred walk-on spots at the Division I level. But once he got a firsthand look at Carnegie Mellon, he knew he’d found a fit, and more than 4,000 yards later, he hasn’t looked back.

Western Pennsylvania might be considered the “Cradle of Quarterbacks” but right now, you could call the City of Pittsburgh the “Receptacle of Running Backs.” Not just in the region, but in the city are four backs who are among the best in their leagues.

Advertise with us

It starts at the top, where Le’Veon Bell is perhaps the NFL’s No. 1 at his position, and DeAngelo Williams might even have a claim for top backup. Then there’s Pitt’s James Conner, who has become a star on the biggest stage of college football thanks to his triumphs on and off the field.

After that, you get to Hines and Benger, the two doing their best work off the usual radar. In his first season in college, all the 5-foot-11, 220-pound Hines has done for the Dukes (5-3) is run for 959 yards — fifth most in FCS — and six touchdowns while being named a STATS FCS freshman of the year candidate. All at a school he’d never even heard of until the summer.

“I had no clue about Duquesne at all,” he said with a laugh. “When they called me, I thought they were green.”

It was a confluence of factors that put Hines on the Bluff. Running back Rafiq Douglas, a second-team All-Northeast Conference pick last year, abruptly left the team in the offseason. So the Dukes contacted Hines, who had to choose between picking another college or doing a semester of prep school with hopes of making it to Richmond in January.

He liked the sound of opportunity knocking at Duquesne, with a returning starter gone, and made his decision to head north. After mostly keeping to himself the first week of training camp, Hines became fast friends with his offensive linemen and fellow running back P.J. Fulmore, a former Cardinal Wuerl North Catholic standout. After getting just five carries in Week 1 at Youngstown State, Hines has been on a tear ever since.

Advertise with us

“I wouldn’t say I expected it,” said Hines, a graduate of Fike High School where he was nicknamed “Baby Gurley” after current Los Angeles Rams star Todd Gurley. “But I knew I had it in me.”

While Hines has just arrived on the local scene, Benger has been cemented since last year. He led all of Division III in rushing last season, and with at least two games left in 2016, he sits fourth with 1,226 yards. A 5-8, 185-pound junior who in high school was flat-out told by an Ivy League team that he was too small, Benger has done nothing but overcome Type 1 diabetes and come up big for the Tartans (5-3).

“That’s something that’s been a bit of a challenge, but being an athlete, you’re kind of held to a higher standard,” said Benger, who was diagnosed when he was 5, wears a glucose monitor on his hip even when he plays and uses a finger-prick meter mid-game.

Benger, a top-notch student who’s more likely to enter the business world than pro football after college, hadn’t really thought about his place among Pittsburgh backs. He doesn’t mind the relative anonymity of playing Division III ball, but sees Bell as a special player at the NFL level and called Conner “an idol” for the way he runs and defeated cancer.

“To be mentioned or considered as part of that group is an honor to me,” Benger said. “I’m happy that’s the company I’m being associated with.”

Advertise with us

The new guy, Hines, laughed — just like he did at the thought of how he ended up here — when asked what’s in the Pittsburgh water when it comes to elite running backs.

“Well, I don’t know,” he said. “I guess we’re just workhorses.”

PSAC West

This weekend is the final Saturday of PSAC West play, and three teams could wind up as division champion. Division II No. 6 California (8-0, 6-0) would clinch by beating No. 24 Edinboro (8-1, 5-1) at home. But if Edinboro wins and No. 11 IUP (7-1, 5-1) beats Mercyhurst, it will create a three-way tie at 6-1 with no head-to-head tiebreaker. In that case, the PSAC would draw a ping pong ball to determine its representative in the PSAC title game Nov. 19.

Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.