Greg Botta openly admits Carter Henderson has always been one of his favorites.
So when one of his former standout linebackers at Franklin Regional High School asked to meet with him in 2014, Botta didn’t hesitate. Henderson was in the midst of spring practice under first-year Penn State coach James Franklin and had become, as Botta put it, “disillusioned.”
As his high school coach remembers it, Henderson’s desire coming out of Franklin Regional was to suit up in front of 100,000-plus fans on Saturdays — even if that meant spending all game on the sideline. Or contributing only on special teams. Or not playing at all until his senior year. Henderson was one of the preferred walk-ons, termed “run-ons” by former Nittany Lions coach Bill O’Brien, in the 2013 class, but his vision for himself began to shift.
“I’m just not getting a chance here, coach,” Botta recalls Henderson telling him. “I was, like, second or third on the depth chart when O’Brien was here and now I’m no longer on the field.”
“And?” Botta replied.
“Well I’m just not getting a shot, and I think I can play up here.”
Read More
“And?” Botta said again. “What do you want me to say? That wasn’t your goal when you came up here.”
Take the tough love, combine it with another season on the bench, and enter Duquesne. Then fast-forward to last weekend, and there was Henderson making an interception, weaving through defenders for a go-ahead third-quarter touchdown that sparked a 34-20 comeback win against Dayton.
Now, in his own words, Duquesne’s standout redshirt junior who played in every game last year but now leads the team in tackles “couldn’t be happier.”
Henderson, who has started all three games at outside linebacker in his second season with the Dukes (2-1) after transferring from Penn State, has been credited with 23 stops, four quarterback hurries, a fumble recovery and, of course, that game-changing pick-six from 23 yards out last Saturday at Rooney Field. Oh, and he continues to be what Botta called “a coach’s dream” for Jerry Schmitt, who had Henderson set to play for him three years ago.
“We thought he was coming to Duquesne, and like a day or two later, [Penn State] wanted him to make a decision,” said the Dukes’ 12th-year coach. “He decided to go ahead and try the big time. It all worked out, I think, for the best.”
In a linebacking corps that also features reigning Northeast Conference defensive player of the year Christian Kuntz at the other outside spot, plus former NEC rookie of the year Nathan Stone and another Penn State transfer in Gary Wooten on the inside, the 5-foot-11, 215-pound Henderson has more than held his own.
“I’ll be honest, it’s not unexpected,” said Schmitt, who led the Dukes to their first outright NEC championship and NCAA playoff berth last year. “We have Kuntz and Stone, but last year, Carter was right there with them. He was just flying under the shadow of those guys.”
Now Henderson, always in a loose, long-sleeved shirt under his jersey since his junior year of high school, is just flying to the ball.
The Dayton interception was only the second of his career, the first coming in last year’s season-ending first-round playoff loss to William & Mary. He never even had one in high school, nor did he have a single carry as a tight end at Franklin Regional, so it’s unclear where his return abilities and nose for the end zone came from. Sure, some of his defensive linemen turned into offensive linemen with alacrity, but he followed their impromptu blocks perfectly to score.
“He’s an instinctive player, is what he is,” said Botta, who made sure to text Henderson the next day. “He kind of lacked that overall D-I, big-time football speed. And maybe a little bit of size he needed, too, to play at that level, but … things just worked out.”
Henderson — one of three former Nittany Lions starting on the Dukes defense along with Wooten and cornerback Daquan Worley — still follows his old school a bit from afar, but his weekends are more active now. His family gets to come watch him, his mom helps organize pregame tailgates, and Saturday’s 1:05 p.m. kickoff against Kennesaw State (1-1) is homecoming.
“I liked Penn State, but I was really happy with the move here,” said Henderson, a finance major. “The school’s great, the football’s great. I landed at Duquesne, and I haven’t looked back since.”
Brian Batko: bbatko@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BrianBatko.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.