Just as many schools had been predicting, the numbers look better under the NCAA's new Graduation Success Rate than they do under the graduation rates calculated by the federal Department of Education.
For some, such as Pitt, the numbers still could be better, though.
The GSR, released yesterday, includes transfer data. Unlike the federal method, athletes in good academic standing who leave a school are not counted against its graduation rates and those who transfer in and graduate are counted toward the rates.
The GSR is one component of the NCAA's academic reform campaign. Early next year, the NCAA will release its Academic Progress Rate, which uses a point system to assess current scholarship athletes according to their graduation track and calculate a grade for each team.
Teams that don't make the cut -- which will be around a 50 percent projected graduation rate -- could be subject to the loss of scholarships or other penalties.
The first GSR numbers are based on a four-year window of freshmen who entered school between 1995-98 and were given six years to graduate.
While the GSR numbers represent an increase in graduation rates in all 15 eligible sports at Pitt compared with the federal numbers, they are still low in two sports at the school that have been singled out for low graduation rates under the federal system -- men's basketball and football.
GRADUATION RATES
The new NCAA rates do not penalize schools for transfers. The federal rate still counts transfers as athletes who do not graduate from their original school.
NCAA rate%
Federal rate%
Pitt
Football
48
31
Men's basketball
29
13
Baseball
77
54
Women's basketball
83
60
?Penn State
Football
84
77
Men's basketball
64
54
Baseball
72
70
Women's basketball
85
83
West Virginia
Football
64
52
Men's basketball
67
63
Baseball
57
24
Women's basketball
67
38
Duquesne
Football
81
n.a.
Men's basketball
83
56
Baseball
73
69
Women's basketball
100
91
Robert Morris
Men's basketball
100
50
Women's basketball
80
64
Source: NCAA
The Panthers basketball numbers go from 13 percent to 29 percent under the GSR. In football, it increases from 31 percent to 48 percent.
The GSR numbers are still below the NCAA average for those sports.
Pitt athletic director Jeff Long said those numbers had improved and that would be reflected as more current numbers are calculated.
"If you take a look at where we were and where we've come from, we're in much different places," Long said. "We don't hide from these numbers. But, at the same time, these numbers are from a time that the university and our athletic department were in a much different place.
"We are a dramatically different picture now academically and athletically than we were in the era that is reflected by these numbers."
Panthers basketball coach Jamie Dixon, who arrived as an assistant in 1999, just after the GSR freshman reporting period ended, has concentrated a lot on his players' academics.
"I knew that was something we were going to face," he said. "The significant thing is [that] our classes since then are 100 percent, 100 percent, just short of 100 percent and will be 100 percent. It's obviously a significant increase -- near perfect in graduation rates.
"We knew the rules were going to change. We knew we had to recruit guys that were going to graduate or we were going to pay for it with loss of scholarships or other penalties. I knew what we were up against."
Penn State's numbers go from strong to stronger with the GSR. The football graduation rate goes from 77 percent under the federal standards to 84 percent under the GSR. Men's basketball climbs from 54 percent to 64 percent. Seven of the Nittany Lions' 25 sports have a 100 percent GSR.
"I'll guarantee you one thing -- if you're a [football] player here, [coach Joe Paterno] knows your GPA better than he knows your 40 time," Penn State defensive coordinator Tom Bradley said.
West Virginia sees a 12 percent rise in football, from 52 percent to 64 percent, and a smaller increase in men's basketball, 63 percent to 67 percent; but its women's basketball rate jumps from 38 percent to 67 percent.
At Duquesne, the men's basketball rate jumps from 56 percent under the federal measure to 83 percent with the GSR. Each of the school's other 16 eligible sports see the numbers either jump or stay the same, and all but crew are above the GSR average.
"The numbers are validation of how Duquesne University conducts itself as an athletic department that never compromises when it comes to academic excellence," first-year athletic director Greg Amodio said.
Robert Morris wasn't eligible in football, but eight of its other 12 sports shoot up to 100 percent in the GSR, including men's basketball, which is at 50 percent, under the federal standards.
Data for each school's overall rates were not released.
The numbers from each sport reflect an increase under the GSR calculations, although men's basketball still has the lowest rate, followed by football, baseball and wrestling.
The overall NCAA men's basketball graduation rate under the federal system is 44 percent. With GSR adjustments, it is 58 percent. For Division I football, it goes from 54 percent to 64 percent.
The top Division I sport in GSR is women's lacrosse (94 percent), followed by women's gymnastics, field hockey and women's fencing, each at 93 percent.
Because the NCAA is the only body that calculates transfer data in this way into graduation rates, there is no way to compare its GSR numbers to the federal numbers for all students or non-athletes.
"It's a very important shift in the way we calculate graduation rates," NCAA President Myles Brand said in a teleconference.
"I urge the federal Department of Education to adopt this more accurate way of accounting."
(For complete national results and graduation rates of all teams at each school, go to ncaa.org.)




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.