Sam Darnold could’ve been a Pittsburgh Steeler this season. Reports indicated that they wanted him under center. He would’ve been a perfect fit. He chose the Seattle Seahawks instead. Sunday evening showed he made the correct decision.
I remember last March when Darnold signed with Seattle. Part of me wondered why he chose to play for an unproven head coach, for a team that just traded away one of its top pass catchers.
I thought Darnold would flop with the Seahawks. Again, Sunday evening showed he made the correct decision.
I won’t pretend that Darnold was the lone reason the Seahawks won Super Bowl LX. He’s the definition of a “system quarterback,” a player who will win you games by preventing mistakes, rather than with his jaw-dropping talent.
But we’re seeing more and more that “system quarterbacks” can take a team pretty far in today’s NFL. The system needs to be right — and that just wasn’t the case in Pittsburgh.
It could’ve been argued that the Steelers were the better option. Even if they weren’t willing to offer as much money, or as many years, that they were the team that gave him the best shot to win.
Read More
Similar to Seattle, they had a defensive-minded head coach, but theirs had already won a championship.
Similar to Seattle, they were a team built to win through its defense, one that featured far more notable names than the one in Seattle.
Similar to Seattle, they had a dynamic duo at receiver and a young running back who could catch passes out of the backfield.
But Darnold saw the truth. Seattle had an actual vision. It wasn’t as sexy and didn’t include as many notable names. But it was a vision fit for today’s NFL. The Seahawks were swimming forward.
They were having consistent success through the draft, not only in the first round, where they found standouts such as Jaxon Smith-Njigba and Devon Witherspoon, but also in the later rounds where they landed Kenneth Walker, AJ Barner, Zach Charbonnet. How many Steelers skill players would you take ahead of anyone in that group?
When Darnold signed, the Seahawks continued to spend money the right way. They added veterans who’d be comfortable in a lesser role such as Cooper Kupp and DeMarcus Lawrence, while the Steelers pretended Jalen Ramsey and Darius Slay Jr. were still in their respective primes.
While the Seahawks pushed forward, properly combining their abundance of young talent with well calculated free agency and trade acquisitions, the Steelers continued to tread water. They were the same team, more or less, that they had been for years, and Darnold saw it.
If Darnold would’ve come here, he would’ve experienced another first-round exit. He would’ve remained a bridge quarterback, a guy you sign to fill time before finding the true next guy. Now, he’s a Super Bowl champion.
Fans should hope that this coaching change will end this harsh reality. But early on, it’s still hard to see this franchise being a Sam Darnold away from a seventh Lombardi Trophy.
There is no young talent, or at least not enough to make a true difference. The draft results haven’t been nearly good enough.
There seems to be no long-term vision. Mike McCarthy is nearly a decade older than the man that he replaced, and Brian Angelichio, a 53-year-old first-time offensive coordinator, isn’t much of a sweetener.
It’s hard to picture the next quarterback like Darnold, one who could carry the team deep into the playoffs if the circumstances were correct, viewing this to be the ideal landing spot. Everything about the Steelers franchise feels stale, outdated or underwhelming.
Darnold noticed it last spring. Others will likely recognize it again when free agency opens this year. The Steelers can keep operating with this same, predictable approach. And while they do, other teams will keep winning Super Bowls — even ones with Sam Darnold as their starting quarterback.
Three thoughts
1. My biggest takeaway from this year’s Super Bowl is that the entire AFC absolutely stunk this year. I’ve known this for quite some time now, but man did Sunday evening drive the point home. How in the world did teams with Patrick Mahomes, Josh Allen and Lamar Jackson on their respective rosters not get further than this Patriots team? Heck, two of those three squads didn’t make the playoffs at all! It’s no wonder why 10 coaches were handed their walking papers this year.
2. I still think Drake Maye is a good quarterback, but it goes to show that you can’t rely on defense to do everything whenever you face a quality opponent. Maye skated throughout the postseason. His poor play — and oh, was he bad — went mostly unpunished throughout the playoffs. His team needed him to be Superman on Sunday. It was his time to do the carrying and he couldn’t deliver.
3. I don’t care to hear anyone’s opinion about the Super Bowl halftime show ever again. Every year it’s the same story. Some people hate it. Some people love it. Some people are offended by it. Some people are empowered by it. Sounds like everything else that exists in our world. I thought the Super Bowl was a football game anyway? If you were to be outraged by anything from Sunday, it should’ve been the Patriots offense.
Most Valuable Player
Jason Myers
Justice for kickers! Myers scored 17 of his team’s 29 points in the biggest game of the season. If he played poorly, New England might’ve eventually found a rhythm and won the game. I was fine with Walker being named this year’s Super Bowl MVP, but I personally felt Myers was more deserving.
Least Valuable Player
Super Bowl commercials
Remember when those used to be good? It felt like for years, marketing teams would spend endless time creating unique, engaging concepts that would capture our attention during breaks in gameplay. It was something a large chunk of our society looked forward to. Now, it’s a hodgepodge of AI slop and celebrity cameos. Isn’t that what we all have Facebook for?
Question of the week
Are you ready for more Olympic hockey?
I’ve enjoyed watching the United States women’s team dominate so far. Let’s hope we see the same for the men’s team, which plays its first game Thursday against Latvia.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.