The commentary below contains opinion. The author’s name has been withheld at the writer’s request.
The Penguins have been ravaged by injuries. They have lost Sidney Crosby for a long stretch of games. They have lost Evgeni Malkin to injury, as well, though he is back playing again. They have had to do the same plug-and-play roster manipulation game as the Steelers because they have had so many injuries to navigate.
And like the Steelers, the Penguins have been incredibly resilient and have found ways to win and to keep themselves in the playoff chase. They beat Columbus, 1-0, Thursday to maintain their position tied for third in the Metro division. They have 40 points, which is more than every team in the Eastern Conference except Boston, Washington and the Islanders.
They have clearly been resourceful and they have kept themselves afloat, and that’s all they’ve needed to do while they wait to get healthy.
That, however, is where comparisons to the Steelers should end. The Steelers are a great story but they are not Super Bowl contenders. They are an easy team to root for, but there is a ceiling. They are still too limited offensively to believe they can win four playoff games (including the Super Bowl) and win a championship.
If the Steelers were getting Ben Roethlisberger back, if James Conner was going to be 100 percent healthy and JuJu Smith-Schuster was going to come back at 100 percent, then it would be different. Those things aren’t happening, though, and so the Steelers are not going anywhere even if they make the playoffs.
Read More
The Penguins on the other hand will be getting all of their players back eventually. They will get Crosby back, they will have Malkin healthy again and they will get guys like Patric Hornqvist back. And once they do, this team has the look of one capable of making a long run in the playoffs.
The Penguins last year looked a little old and a little slow. It seemed like the end of the Crosby dynasty had arrived and the Penguins weren’t going to be a factor any more in the playoffs. There was even some talk about breaking up the team and starting over, maybe even moving on from Jim Rutherford and Mike Sullivan.
But the Penguins added some speed, some youth and they added a little bit of grit and toughness, too. They have recommitted to playing responsibly defensively and working to get those tough goals that defined them during their most recent Stanley Cup run.
Crosby and Malkin will always give them a chance to be dangerous, but they have needed help. The Penguins also have lacked depth, but all these injuries have allowed Sullivan to play a lot of younger players and develop depth for a playoff run.
The only question facing the Penguins has been at goalie. Matt Murray is the starter and has the two Stanley Cup titles to prove he is a championship-level goalie. He hasn’t been consistent this year, though, and so he has temporarily lost his job to Tristan Jarry. Murray should still be the goalie once the playoffs come, and as we have seen in the past, he is capable of shining when the lights are the brightest.
In the meantime, though, Jarry had been spectacular and has been a big reason the Penguins have been able to stay afloat. It doesn’t matter who is playing right now for the Penguins, all that matters is they keep acquiring points and keep themselves in the playoff chase. They just need to get through January and still be in playoff position. And at that point, we also know Rutherford will make the necessary moves at the trade deadline to push the Penguins over the top.
It is fashionable to compare the Steelers and Penguins this year because both are going through similar issues with injuries and adversity. And both have been able to overcome them. But only the Penguins have the ability to get back into championship form, and they will once they get Crosby and company back healthy and fully engaged in the season.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.