Softball or basketball?
Basketball or softball?
Claire Oberdorf hears these questions frequently thanks to her proficiency in each sport at Division I Marist College, located in Poughkeepsie, N.Y.
A sophomore from Greensburg Salem High School, Oberdorf averages 11.5 points, 5.2 rebounds, 2.8 assists and leads the Metro Atlantic Athletic Conference in minutes played as the Red Foxes’ starting point guard.
In softball, the talented shortstop was recently named the MAAC Co-Preseason Player of the Year.
The honor came on the heels of a freshman season in which Oberdorf hit a team-best .376 with 7 homers, 39 RBIs, 37 runs and 16 stolen bases in 18 tries. She earned spots on the National Fastpitch Coaches’ Association Top 10 Freshman list, the NFCA and ECAC All-Region First Team and was named the MAAC Rookie of the Year.
Little wonder this 5-foot-6 dynamo has been called a “Godsend” by coaches Brian Giorgis in basketball and Joe Ausanio in softball.
“I really can’t pick one sport over the other, because I love playing both,” said Oberdorf, who produced 18 points, 8 rebounds and 6 assists in a win against Monmouth Saturday. “I just enjoy competing in whatever I’m playing at the time. It’s a privilege to play both at the Division I level, and I’m enjoying every second of it.”
Not only is Oberdorf proving to be double trouble for Marist opponents, but she and elder sibling Jayne are quite the sister act on the softball field.
The latter is a top-flight senior pitcher who also earned a spot on the Preseason All-MAAC team. Jayne Oberdorf went 16-4 last season in leading Marist to a school-record 45 victories and a berth in the NCAA regionals. She is the reigning MAAC Pitcher of the Year and was the MVP of the 2016 MAAC tournament.
“To have the opportunity to play with my sister is awesome,” said Claire Oberdorf, who won a WPIAL softball title with Jayne in 2013. “I never would have thought that I’d get to play two extra years of softball with her. I even got a chance to be her catcher a few times. That was fun, because I know exactly what she likes to throw. It was like we were playing in the backyard again.”
As a two-sport athlete who carries a 3.2 grade-point average, Claire Oberdorf is an exemplary multi-tasker.
Her schedule works this way: She competes in the fall exhibition season in softball, then joins the basketball team when practice commences in mid-October. She plays basketball exclusively until season’s end, which, at Marist, often stretches to the NCAA tournament.
The Red Foxes (13-15, 10-8 MAAC) had made nine consecutive NCAA appearances until the streak was broken last season. Oberdorf will return to the softball team, which opened the season last Saturday, in mid- to late March.
“To play two Division I sports at such a high level is incredibly unique; it’s amazing, really,” said Ausanio, who looked on in disbelief last season as Oberdorf joined his team 11 games into the season and promptly earned MAAC Freshman of the Week honors. “It’s really hard with academics. And then, just the wear and tear on the body of having to go from season to season with no breaks is difficult. She’s a special talent.”
A former pitcher in the Pirates’ organization, Ausanio assumes some risk in allowing Oberdorf to play basketball, given she is on a softball scholarship. He often cringes when he sees her go crashing onto the floor with her signature, win-at-all-costs style.
“Claire doesn’t have any speed except fast-forward,” Ausanio said of Oberdorf, who averaged 26 points as a senior on the Greensburg Salem basketball team. “She’s the first kid to take a charge. The first to dive onto the floor for a loose ball. And she’ll mix it up with kids who are much, much bigger. She doesn’t mind putting herself in harm’s way. So, I had reservations, but I also know that basketball has always been an important part of her life. And when the basketball team had a void and needed players last season [four transferred and another suffered a season-ending injury], I suggested that she help them out.”
Ausanio paused, before adding, “I think she’s seriously exceeded expectations.”
In an interesting twist, Jayne Oberdorf is arguably every bit as talented as Claire in basketball. In fact, there was talk of her also playing basketball this season, but her focus was squarely on finishing strong in softball.
The Oberdorf’s basketball genes come from mom, Jeannie, a former guard at Allegheny College who would make the girls shoot 100 free throws a day in preparation for the season. If they made fewer than 75, they had to start over.
This brought out the competitive spirit in Claire and Jayne.
“When we’d play one-on-one, some games would end with a fistfight, or with somebody running away from the other one,” Claire Oberdorf said. “We would challenge each other, and, in the end, we just wanted to make each other better. We always learned to play hard and to give your best in everything that you do.”
At Marist College, the Oberdorfs are doubling down on those lessons.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.