Former Gateway High School football receiver and defensive back Aidan Howard is suing the University of Virginia in federal court, alleging he was forced to fight another first-year player as a kind of hazing ritual.
The Aug. 12 fight, complete with a locker room ring circled off with athletic tape, flashing lights, loud music and announcements simulating a prizefight, was watched by more than 100 people, the complaint said. It ended after Mr. Howard sustained severe eye injuries, immediately experiencing double vision in his right eye and significant pain. He also felt sick to his stomach and his head hurt.
He later was diagnosed with a concussion and was told he could not practice.
Six days later, Mr. Howard was granted a release from the national letter of intent he signed with Virginia. He transferred to Robert Morris University with hopes of playing football this year. But, according to the lawsuit filed in the Western District of Pennsylvania, an examination a month later showed that the brawl left him with a broken orbital bone, which required surgery.
“[I]t is unclear if he will ever be able to play football again,” wrote attorney C. James Zeszutek.
In an interview Thursday, Mr. Zeszutek added, “He had surgery at the end of September for the fracture of the orbital bone, and he’s still seeing a physician.”
In addition to the university, the lawsuit names as defendants UVA president Teresa Sullivan, athletic director Craig Littlepage, wide receivers coach Marques Hagans, graduate assistant Famika Anae, and fellow wide receivers Doni Dowling and David Eldridge.
Mr. Zeszutek said the university didn’t get in touch with his client until Mr. Howard had left the school.
University spokesman Anthony P. de Bruyn said in a statement that the school was aware of Mr. Howard’s allegations.
“The university has been actively investigating these reports consistent with its obligations under the law and university policy,” he said. “The university does not comment on ongoing litigation and will not make any further statements regarding this case.”
The lawsuit includes civil rights claims, as well as claims under Title IX and the Americans with Disabilities Act. It alleges Mr. Howard suffered abuse, harassment and discrimination.
The 6-foot-4, 195-pound teen signed a letter of intent with Virginia on Feb. 3 and began attending summer school there in July.
According to the complaint, older players made Mr. Howard “the target of bullying and harassing conduct because of his soft-spoken and mild-mannered nature. Indeed, these upperclassmen, including defendants Dowling and Eldridge, targeted Aidan because they perceived him to be ‘soft’ and ‘not manly’ like other student-athletes in the football program,” the lawsuit said.
Mr. Howard, who said he was diagnosed at Virginia with a learning disability, also alleges that he was bullied because he could not grasp the Cavaliers’ offense. Upperclassmen referred to Mr. Howard as “stupid,” “dumb,” “slow,” and “retarded,” the lawsuit said. Other players, with coaches’ knowledge, would ostracize Mr. Howard, forcing him to eat lunch and dinner alone, it continued.
The lawsuit also alleged that Mr. Howard witnessed Mr. Dowling and Mr. Eldridge and others with the team force first-year players to participate in fights and wrestling matches while naked or partially naked, “an act referred to at UVA as ‘ramming.’”
“Aidan had been harassed and taunted for a period of time, sort of orchestrated into this arranged fight between him and another freshman,” Mr. Zeszutek said. “And Aidan felt that if he didn’t go forward with this, he would continue to be harassed by these individuals. ... But what occurred was almost like an orchestration of a prizefight.”
The Aug. 12 fight, the complaint alleges, was between Mr. Howard and another first-year wide receiver, Hasise Dubois, after a team practice, as a part of Mr. Howard’s “initiation” and “to prove his toughness and manliness.”
Mr. Howard claimed in the lawsuit that he did not want to fight but felt “as though he had no choice.”
More than 100 people watched the fight, but none tried to stop it, the suit says. Several players attempted to use their cell phones to record the fight, but Mr. Howard said he heard Mr. Anae, the graduate assistant, yell, “No phones.”
After it ended, Mr. Howard went to the team trainer for treatment, but, he claims, no one from the university ever reached out to him until his father requested his son be released from the team.
Virginia granted the release, noting that it was because of “conduct of others within the university,” with no further comment. The lawsuit alleges that no one was ever reprimanded.
According to Virginia team rules for football players, there is to be no hazing, initiations or rookie nights.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard. Megan Ryan contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.