Upon hitting her first collegiate home run, Lindsay Reicoff of California University of Pennsylvania dropped her bat and briskly circled the bases. No jogging. No fancy home run trot.
“Business,” Reicoff said, laughing. “All business.”
Perhaps Reicoff didn’t know any better, given she was a self-described “contact hitter” at Chartiers Valley High School. Or, maybe she realized this was about to become a regular occurrence.
“We changed a couple things with my batting stance – and there it went,” said Reicoff, who launched that first homer in the sixth game of her freshman season. “I started to put more weight on my back foot. It changed everything.”
It transformed Reicoff into, arguably, the most prolific power hitter in the rich history of Cal softball.
The senior first baseman enters the season – which opens next Friday at the Snowbird Tournament in Myrtle Beach, S.C. – with 42 career home runs, five shy of Cal’s all-time record. That total also ranks third among active NCAA Division II players. Her 70 career walks tie her for first in school history and her 139 RBIs rank seventh.
A Scott Township resident, Reicoff was recently one of 50 Division II players named to the National Fastpitch Coaches Association Player of the Year Watch List. Cal teammates shortstop Emily Price and pitcher Alex Sagl also made the list.
Cal was an NCAA tournament semifinalist last season and finished with a 43-13 record.
“It’s pretty awesome to be recognized for such an honor,” Reicoff said. “For people to actually know who you are and to think that highly of you, it means a lot.”
A two-time NFCA All-American, Reicoff hit a school-record 19 home runs last season, ranking ninth nationally. That total more than doubled any player in the Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference. Reicoff also led the PSAC with an .817 slugging percentage, .513 on-base percentage, 52 runs scored, 56 RBIs and a school-record 31 walks.
And to think, she arrived at Cal four years ago known more for her arm than her bat. A knee injury in her freshman season sidetracked her pitching career and fast-tracked her to offensive stardom. Reicoff was 2-0 with a 4.05 ERA in six starts as a freshman.
“We thought futuristically that she was going to be an outstanding pitcher,” legendary coach Rick Bertagnolli said of Reicoff, who holds the Chartiers Valley record for strikeouts with 176. “But due to the injuries, we had to make a change. We told her that we would make her the best first baseman and hitter possible. Well, seeing the speed of the ball coming off of her bat was a ‘Wow’ moment. We then taught her to lift the ball a little bit and thought she might hit some home runs. She grabbed hold of those reins and has taken it to a different level.”
Bertagnolli’s program is at a different level. Entering his 23rd season, Bertagnolli has led Cal to the NCAA tournament 20 times and to national titles in 1997 and 1998. He is 785-247 at Cal and oversaw an 88-game winning streak in conference play from 1994-99. The Vulcans have won seven consecutive PSAC West titles and are the preseason favorites to do it again.
“The environment here brings out a different side of athletes,” said Reicoff, one of six WPIAL alums on the team. “We always say, ‘We’re playing for California, not ourselves.’ It’s all about giving 100 percent.”
Reicoff gives 100 percent in the world of academia, too. She carries a 3.2 grade-point average in biology with a pre-med concentration. She has a minor in chemistry. She plans to continue with her education after this season, but would like it to coincide with a coaching job. That is not surprising, given her bloodlines.
Her father, Jeff, is the softball coach at Chartiers Valley and mom, Mary Lou, a former basketball player at Edinboro, once served as an assistant. Dad played baseball at West Virginia Wesleyan, where younger brother, Ryan, a senior at Chartiers Valley, will play next fall.
For now, Reicoff looks to continue her assault on the Cal record book, while trying to get her team back to the Final Four – and beyond.
“Now that we got there, I want that feeling again,” Reicoff said. “I want more. We have a bunch of fighters on this team, they never give up. In high school, we used to have a saying, ‘Refuse to Lose.’ That’s what this group is like. We want to win it all.”



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.