Tray Woodall and his older sister, Shataya grew up sharing shoes.
And even now that Woodall, a junior on Pitt's basketball team, no longer is living in underprivileged areas of Brooklyn, N.Y., and Paterson, N.J., that tradition continues.
Every time Shataya Ratliff, 25, visits her younger brother in Oakland, "she always leaves with two or three pair of shoes," he said.
Woodall played in all 34 games last season, making four starts, for a Pitt basketball team that earned a No. 1 seed in the NCAA tournament and generated $13.6 million in basketball revenue. His coach, Jamie Dixon, is the university's highest-paid employee, pulling in about $2 million annually. Athletic director Steve Pederson earns about $600,000.
But Woodall and every other athlete at Pitt who earns a "full ride" faces an annual scholarship shortfall for academic-related expenses that the National College Players Association estimates is $2,986.
Rochester native Derek Moye is Penn State's top wide receiver. He led the team in catches last season and helped the Nittany Lions advance to the Outback Bowl.
The Penn State football team raised $72.7 million in revenue last season, and the athletic department tallied more than $30 million in profit, according to U.S. Department of Education figures. Coach Joe Paterno earns more than $1 million per year. But Moye and the rest of his teammates on scholarship faced a scholarship shortfall of $3,924, according to the NCPA study.
"We don't have enough time to get a job and a lot of us don't really come from families that have the means to give us extra money to support us up here," Moye said. "You kind of just have to live day to day."
The study, conducted by the NCPA, an advocacy group for college athletes, and the Ithaca College Graduate Sport Management Research Team, found the average scholarship shortfall for athletes who receive a full ride in 2009-10 was $2,951 annually. The shortfall is the difference between the cost of attendance, which includes estimates for books, supplies, transportation, food and additional expenses, and the financial aid given to student athletes.
Schools in California and Connecticut are required by law to inform athletes of the disparity between their athletic scholarships and the cost of attendance.
The shortfalls and external pressures that rose amid the recent rush to realign athletic conferences in a mad dash for television revenue, prompted the NCAA recently to approve an additional $2,000 a year that schools can award athletes.
"This is about trying to cover more of the legitimate expenses of the cost of attending college for our student athletes," NCAA president Mark Emmert said in a news conference announcing the changes.
Woodall first heard the news on TV and immediately told several of his teammates.
At first, they didn't believe him.
"They all thought I was lying," Woodall said. "I said, 'No, I don't play with money.' "
Although the NCAA approved the measure, there is no guarantee athletes will receive the additional funds. The change is optional and must be approved by individual athletic conferences before it is adopted by schools. Many sports business experts predict only the country's biggest and wealthiest conferences will allow their schools to pay the additional aid. That means Duquesne athletes, who face an estimated $1,150 annual shortfall, and Robert Morris athletes, who face an estimated $2,600 shortfall, likely will not benefit from the change.
The NCPA applauded the NCAA's decision, but said it does not go far enough.
"It's a long time coming," said NCPA president Ramogi Huma, a former linebacker at UCLA. "It still falls short... But at least it's upward movement."
Since some schools can close the gap with the new money, Huma said, the NCAA is creating competitive inequality because other schools still will saddle their athletes with extra costs.
On the same day the NCAA announced its scholarship change, 339 student athletes from a handful of Division I schools sent the NCAA a letter asking it to set aside even more money in a special fund for each athlete. The fund could be accessed for education-related expenses while athletes are in school, and the students would receive the rest upon graduation, no strings attached.
Although major college athletics is increasing its wealth, most athletic departments operate at a deficit. High administrative salaries and funding for non-revenue sports drain department funds. Some schools might cut sports programs to cover the additional costs associated with the NCAA's change.
Critics of the NCAA's plan say it compromises the pillars of amateurism, although Emmert disputed any notion the NCAA's change reflects a "pay-for-play" model.
"The dividing line on pay for play is very sharp and clear," he said. "This is most certainly not pay for play."
Huma asserted that "amateurism was always a myth." As soon as schools offered scholarships to their athletes, Huma said, college athletics no longer was a competition among amateurs.
If Pitt were to approve the $2,000 payment, it would not be the first time that its athletes received a stipend.
In his book, "King Football," Michael Oriard cites news reports of the late 1920s and early '30s noting that a system of subsidies was in place at that time, with Pitt football players receiving $650 a year in 1929 in addition to tuition and books. Pitt players also refused to play in the 1937 Rose Bowl unless they got adequate spending money and a two-week vacation after the game.
"The football program at Pitt had long epitomized the professionalism of big-time college football," Oriard wrote of that era.
Now, the entire system is challenging the merits of amateurism in a multibillion dollar industry. Over four years, an in-state athlete with a full athletic scholarship at Pitt receives about $100,000 in aid.
Boise State president Robert Kustra opposes the change and asked supporters of the increased aid to compare it to "the rest of our students, who are making minimum wage, collecting tips, trying to find their way into their next semester at the university. ... Go back and examine the life of a student athlete in intercollegiate sports in America today and see how privileged they are to be where they are and the opportunities they have."
Student athletes are not saddled with as much debt as their classmates, even with scholarship shortfalls. And student athletes receive benefits -- private tutors, free clothing and meals -- not offered to most college students.
Pitt student Adam Van Scoyoc, 22, is a senior from Manassas, Va., majoring in media and professional communications. He works about 30 hours a week as a waiter at the Cheesecake Factory and spends an additional 15 hours a week as a website manager for a public relations firm.
"I don't have any sympathy at all for athletes," Van Scoyoc said. "Why should I work so much when I'm racking up 14 grand in debt every year and am struggling to pay rent? Meanwhile, they don't face those same challenges at all."
Julia Carpey, a 19-year-old sophomore from Lafayette Hill, Pa., a Philadelphia suburb, is working three unpaid internships and taking 16 credit hours this semester as she pursues degrees in communications and English writing at Pitt. Her parents help her with expenses, but she said she will graduate with thousands of dollars in student-loan debt.
"I don't want to minimize what problems they have," she said. "But it's a little hard to watch them get full rides and extra money. ... We walk out with these student loans, and they walk out scot-free."
But Max Gruder, a linebacker on Pitt's football team, said college athletes struggle to find spending money because their schedules make it difficult to work part-time jobs.
"People always know, if you're a college student, you're going to be broke," he said. "But, if you're a college athlete, it's even worse. You can almost never work. ... You can always make ends meet. It's never been the case where I have no money. But it's not something as an athlete where you can have tons of extra luxuries on the side. I'm not saying we deserve it, but it does get hard sometimes, especially at the end of the month, if you don't manage your money.
"It might not seem like a lot, but $2,000 is everything," he said. "It will make a huge difference and will be very beneficial."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.