In Josh Forbes’ first five seasons as Butler’s baseball coach, he used to talk to his team often about winning a WPIAL championship. But the Golden Tornado always fell short, losing in the semifinals three times and the quarterfinals twice.

So this year, Forbes tried a different approach.

“This was the least we ever talked about a WPIAL championship,” Forbes said. “I would always tell them the only thing that matters is what you’re doing now. When you think about the future so much, it can create anxiety because it’s not real yet. The only thing they should try to control is the present.”

In other words, Forbes wanted his team to live in the moment. And the Golden Tornado ended up enjoying the biggest moment in the history of Butler High School baseball.

Advertise with us

Butler won a WPIAL title.

In 112 seasons of WPIAL championships, that phrase had never been said before.

Forbes had a terrific one-two pitching punch in Kyle Casteel and Nolan Stefaniak and that was key to Butler’s success. But he still had to push all the right buttons for Butler to win the first baseball championship in school history. It was a golden year for a Golden Tornado team that had made a WPIAL final only once before (1992).

For his efforts, Forbes is the Post-Gazette Coach of the Year. The award takes into consideration all coaches in the WPIAL and City League.

While Forbes coached Butler to its first title, what also made the season memorable is he and his wife, Holly, had their first child in the middle of the playoff run.

Advertise with us

“There are a ton of other great coaches out there who are as much or more deserving of this [award] than me,” Forbes said. “I mean, [Indiana’s] Dan Petroff won his second straight state championship. The players make us good. At the end of the day, the players deserve the credit. I was just there for the ride.”

That’s just Forbes being humble. Forbes should be lauded for taking Butler baseball to another level the past few years.

Some of Forbes’ teams were undoubtedly talented. But there was something different about this team that finished 23-4 and had a 16-game winning streak until losing in the PIAA title game to Neshaminy. Seniors Casteel and Stefaniak provided superb pitching, combining for an 18-2 record. Casteel, a West Virginia recruit, was 11-0 with a 0.82 ERA while Stefaniak was 7-2 with a 1.18 ERA. Stefaniak also was the leading hitter with a .372 average.

The team had three other senior starters who came through at different times and in different ways. Senior catcher Mavrik Clement (Pitt recruit) and senior shortstop Boden Lenyk (Division II South Carolina Aiken) were big in the playoffs. The other senior starter was designated hitter Blake Scott.

Butler coach Josh Forbes (center) holds up the WPIAL Class 6A championship trophy while surrounded by four of his senior players. From left, Boden Lenyk, Kyle Casteel, Forbes, Nolan Stefaniak and Mavrik Clement. (Rachel Lenyk photo)

Butler had a penchant for winning close games. The team won three postseason games by one run and a pair by two runs. Butler defeated North Allegheny, 4-2, in the WPIAL title game.

Advertise with us

So, what exactly was different about this team?

“I think they saw in past years what it took to win it all and saw some failures of our other teams,” Forbes said. “I think they just said, ‘I don’t want that to be us.’ I think there were more guys just with this refusal to lose.”

The 33-year-old Forbes was a two-sport athlete in college at Seton Hill. He was the goalkeeper for the soccer team and catcher for the baseball team.

“I don’t know of too many Division II athletes who have recorded a shutout in soccer as a goalkeeper and hit a home run in baseball,” Forbes said. “For a hot moment, I was the big dog on campus. Everyone knew who I was. Being the goalie and catcher was crazy. I got to go to two different type of parties — the baseball parties and the soccer parties.”

Forbes laughed at those college days, but he got pretty serious about coaching not long after he got out of Seton Hill. He is a 2011 graduate of Greenville High School and was a volunteer coach at Greenville for a couple of seasons after his college playing days. He also was an assistant at Wittenberg University in Ohio in 2016-17.

Advertise with us

Forbes was an assistant for four summers (2015-18) with the Butler BlueSox, a former collegiate summer league team that played out of Butler. That’s where he realized he wanted to maybe be a head coach.

Forbes became an assistant at Butler High School under Cody Herald in 2018-19. When Herald stepped down, Forbes became head coach in 2020. But COVID-19 canceled the 2020 season and Forbes had to wait until 2021 for his first game as a head coach. Forbes works in the Butler Area School District in the merit learning program, where he helps students who are deficient in school credits to graduate.

“My thought always was to win a WPIAL championship,” Forbes said. “That was my main goal. I saw we had a lot of talent coming through and some pieces to do it.”

That goal has been accomplished.

“I would love to coach in college again,” Forbes said. “That would be a dream. But right now, I’m happy.”

He’s living in the moment.