Indianapolis is the annual locale where NFL prospects’ bodies are hyper-scrutinized within a fraction of an inch, and it’s serious business.

But there was a joke floating around on social media this week that if Miami star Rueben Bain Jr.’s arms measured less than 31 inches, he simply would be forced to quit football and find a new career path. Sure enough, Bain came in an eighth of an inch shy of hitting that threshold, so apparently it’s time for a future in something other than sports.

In all seriousness, Bain remains one of the top prospects for the 2026 draft in Pittsburgh. The 2025 ACC Defensive Player of the Year had 9.5 sacks for the national runner-up Hurricanes, plus a whopping 15.5 tackles for a loss. But his arms are short — well, relatively short for an NFL edge rusher.

“That’s egregiously short,” NBC Sports analyst Chris Simms, a former NFL quarterback who briefly worked in the league, said Thursday on his podcast. “There’s definitely gonna be a faction of teams in the first round that’s like, ‘Man …’

Advertise with us

“This is unique. We’ve got to talk about it.”

Bain didn’t need long arms to be a unanimous All-American this past season. Neither did Texas A&M’s Cashius Howell, whose arms are even shorter at 30¼ — shortest of any player categorized as an edge rusher at the combine since at least 1999, actually.

But Howell, who began his career at Bowling Green, had 11.5 sacks in 2025 for the Aggies and is widely projected to be a first-round pick, albeit not as high as Bain. It makes for an interesting debate this draft season, the latest iteration of Kyler Murray’s height, Kenny Pickett’s hands and — just a year ago — Will Campbell’s arms.

Campbell is the offensive tackle who went fourth overall to New England. But not before draft analysts questioned his length, or lack thereof, coming out of LSU. His arms measured 32⅝ at the combine, which led some scouts surmising that he would be better off moving to guard.

“For two years nobody had any measurements on me and nobody said anything about my play, so now all of a sudden arm length decides if I’m a good player or not? I think that’s BS,” Campbell deadpanned a year ago at his pro day. “But any decision-makers in the NFL, they don’t really care. It’s all people who don’t coach, and they don’t coach for a reason.”

Advertise with us

That may be, but general managers don’t coach, and they do make decisions. It is their job to lean on the intel of their scouting departments, who are conditioned to size up the physical traits of players and what they mean beyond the film work and statistical evaluations.

This year, it’s elite pass rushers who are the outliers. The Steelers have done such a great job stockpiling outside linebackers that they need not spend too much time on the position in this class. Over the years, they haven’t been obsessed with a rusher’s arms, but they haven’t exactly overlooked it either.

The Steelers snagged Jack Sawyer in the fourth round in their most recent draft, and his drop to that spot despite a highly productive career as a captain for national champion Ohio State was almost certainly due in part to his frame. Sawyer’s pro day measured his arms at 32⅛, but they were a half-inch shorter at the combine, so he was just above the bottom five at his position in Indianapolis.

Nick Herbig (31¼) was another edge defender who didn’t fit the modern archetype at the combine, and if you’ll recall, the narrative surrounding him was that he might need to be an inside linebacker at the next level. The Steelers took their chances on Herbig’s unconventional build, and all he has done since is cement himself as a regular terror for opposing offensive tackles.

The previous two outside linebackers the Steelers invested premium picks in, meaning the first two days of the draft, were Alex Highsmith and T.J. Watt. Both had 33⅛ arms, squarely in the range of what many football people like to see.

Advertise with us

“That’s really what you need when you’re on an edge,” former Steelers defensive coordinator Teryl Austin said a few years ago. “You’re not like a big guy inside, where you’re taking on double-teams. You’re a lot of one-on-ones, getting on the edge of people. If you have long arms, good leverage and good explosiveness, you can play well.”

In 2019, the Steelers took a shot on undersized Northern Illinois defensive end Sutton Smith with one of their three sixth-round picks. Smith was more than a trend-breaker. He basically was unprecedented at just a shade over 6 feet and 233 pounds and with 30¾ arms.

Though he racked up 29 sacks in his final two seasons in the Mid-American Conference, the Steelers were realistic about Smith’s odds of making it. Then-coordinator Keith Butler predicted Smith would help special teams coach Danny Smith more than the defense, at least to start, and there was chatter about moving him to inside linebacker if he didn’t hold up on the outside.

Smith didn’t even make it through August, dealing with injuries while splitting his time between linebacker and fullback.

That’s why you don’t make a habit of betting on the physical exceptions to the longstanding rules. And you certainly have to think long and hard about doing it in the first round.

But Bain and Howell will continue to create plenty of discourse in league circles. Perhaps they’re so quick, powerful and technically sound that their reach won’t matter.