Since Dick Butkus’ death Thursday, the adjectives around his name have been many.
Legendary. Ferocious linebacker. All-time great. Pro Football Hall of Famer. All-Pro.
But don’t forget “former high school football coach in Western Pennsylvania.”
Yes, Butkus was head coach of Montour High School in the WPIAL for one season in 2005. Actually, he didn’t even last the whole season. He quit with two games left and put an end to one of the most bizarre situations in the history of WPIAL football that is worth re-telling.
When asked Friday if Butkus’ role as head coach was a sham, current Montour head coach Lou Cerro paused and agreed.
“That season was hard,” Cerro said.
But it was all made-for-TV.
Butkus was installed as head coach because of a deal ESPN made with the Montour School District for a weekly reality TV show called “Bound For Glory,” which was supposed to chronicle Montour’s season and the team’s efforts to regain their mojo.
Truth be told, the show’s bosses called me in the spring of 2005 and asked for a suggestion of a Western Pennsylvania team that had enjoyed success and then tough times. Montour had been pretty good for a number of years but was 12-45 from 1999 through 2004 and was coming off consecutive 1-8 seasons. Representatives of the show liked the Montour idea, but they never said anything about Butkus being the head coach.
The 2005 season was supposed to be Cerro’s first as Montour’s head coach. The school had hired him away from Seton LaSalle, where he had enjoyed success, going 82-46-1 in 12 years and winning two WPIAL Class 2A titles in 2004 and 2002.
But ESPN got to Montour and had this idea of bringing in Butkus to be the head coach for a year in hopes that Butkus would help bring back some glory to Montour’s program. The thought was it might make for good TV.
Cerro wasn’t exactly sweet Lou over the idea of Butkus being the head coach. The deal was Cerro would be the assistant head coach. But part of the deal was that Montour would get a new scoreboard, weight room, and uniforms. So Cerro went along with the idea.
“At first, I was all for it because we needed all the help we could get,” Cerro said. “People started talking about Montour again, and no one had been talking about Montour for a while.”
Cerro remembers telling the show’s producers that Montour would be lucky to win two games that season. It didn’t matter. The show went on – and in came Butkus to be head coach. He showed up in early August, only shortly before the start of preseason practices.
Television stations and newspapers in Pittsburgh jumped on the news that Butkus was the head coach, even if it was in name only.
“I ran the day-to-day operations,” Cerro said. “[Butkus] would come in every Monday and start doing his thing. I remember there was stuff going on that I had no idea about until I watched the video of the show.”
Needless to say, things didn’t go well. During the season, Butkus lived in a trailer in Harmony and another at Montour. He was very critical of the players on the show.
“He had a lot of personality clashes with my assistant coaches,” Cerro said. “I don’t know what the word is I’m looking for, but it was hard. It was the producer’s show. If I wanted to do something and the producer didn’t like it, I couldn’t do it.”
Montour started the season 1-6 – and then Butkus bolted with two games remaining. Cerro said Butkus told him he left because his contract was to only coach for eight weeks.
“I never heard from him again since the day he walked out of here,” Cerro said.
When Butkus left in 2005, Montour senior linebacker Morgan Singletary said, “I understood most of the stuff he was saying. But at times, it was awkward the way he would yell at us. He wouldn't really talk to us at all during practice; then, he'd come out and start yelling at us at the end. That was awkward.”
Two years after the Butkus ordeal, Montour was indeed bound for glory. Cerro guided Montour to a WPIAL championship game in 2007 and again in 2009, although the Spartans lost both times. In 2011, Montour won the WPIAL Class 3A championship.
A few weeks ago, Cerro became the 37th coach in WPIAL history to win 200 games. The 2005 Butkus season is merely a blip on his coaching screen now. It was mainly in the back of his mind until Thursday when old coaching comrades and friends started texting him about Butkus’ death — and Butkus’ stories.
“We’ve been crushing each other with memories of that show,” Cerro said with a laugh.
It was a painful season for Cerro. But looking back, maybe it wasn’t all that bad.
“The show gave me a truck for that year,” Cerro said. “It lasted 10 years before it fell apart. But hey, it was still a truck.”
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.