The search for Keith Butler’s replacement as defensive coordinator could be a short one because the likely candidate appears to be in-house.
But that doesn’t mean the process won’t become a tricky one for several reasons. Especially because the position would be in title only.
Teryl Austin, who has served as senior defensive assistant/secondary coach for the past three seasons, is in line to succeed Butler, much the same way the Steelers groomed Butler to be the heir apparent to Dick LeBeau seven years ago. Austin has served as defensive coordinator for two other NFL teams – the Detroit Lions and Cincinnati Bengals.
That promotion, though, is likely contingent on the same arrangement Butler had in his role as defensive coordinator since 2015 – that coach Mike Tomlin calls all the defensive signals during a game.
However, even before the Steelers could offer the job to Austin, they still have to interview two external minority candidates for the position under the new league-mandated guidelines of the Rooney Rule, even though Austin is Black.
And, here’s another problem: How many potential candidates would want to become defensive coordinator on a team where they don’t call the defensive signals? Certainly no qualified candidate with coordinator experience would accept that.
Read More
For example, head coaches with defensive experience who were fired after the season – Mike Zimmer, Brian Flores, Vic Fangio – would probably not be interested in the Steelers given the current arrangement.
Is Tomlin likely to cede the responsibility of calling the signals to a new coordinator? At this point, that does not appear likely.
The Steelers defense struggled mightily this season, dropping from third in yards per game in 2020 to 24th, from 29th in rush defense to 32nd and from third to 20th in points allowed.
Granted, the Steelers lost four starters during the offseason – Bud Dupree, Mike Hilton, Steve Nelson and Vince Williams – and were without defensive linemen Stephon Tuitt (personal) and Tyson Alualu (ankle surgery) for most of the season. Inside linebacker Devin Bush also was not the same player coming back from ACL surgery.
None of the replacements for those players performed even close to the same level, especially on the defensive line, though Cam Sutton was asked to play multiple roles in the defense.
So, the question remains: Is the problem what the Steelers are doing defensively or who they are doing it with?
What will Mike Tomlin decide?
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com and Twitter @gerrydulac.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.