(After every Penguins home game, the Post-Gazette will assess how each unit performed and what it means during the playoff push.)
FORWARDS
Grade: B-.
While the two points the Penguins got from this game were important, the way Evgeni Malkin played for the second game in a row might be even more critical to their chances of success during the stretch drive, and beyond. Malkin punctuated his second strong showing of the weekend by scoring the Penguins’ fifth and sixth goals, the latter of which came on a spectacular spinning backhander from inside the left circle. Malkin’s first goal was set up by a nice feed from behind the goal line by Phil Kessel, but what the Penguins really need from Kessel is a goal, considering that he hasn’t scored one in nine games. Even more troubling is that Patric Hornqvist doesn’t have a goal in 13 games or a point in 12. While Hornqvist gives this team a lot more than offense, he can’t go missing from the scoresheet for weeks at a time without it having an impact. Sidney Crosby had three assists, all of them primaries, and Matt Cullen won nine of 11 faceoffs.
DEFENSEMEN
Grade: B-.
Read More
The Penguins’ first four goals were scored by defensemen – Kris Letang (2), Marcus Pettersson and Brian Dumoulin – which makes a little easier to overlook some spotty play in their own zone, like when New York’s Chris Kreider forced goalie Casey DeSmith to stop him three times from close range just over four minutes into the game without having a defenseman touch him. Justin Schultz, in his second appearance after a 53-game absence because of a broken leg, was fairly sharp again, although his game was not without a few flaws, like the turnover that triggered an extended Rangers flurry in the Penguins’ end during the opening period. Pettersson assisted on Dumoulin’s goal – actually, pretty much made it possible with an aggressive forecheck – to give him two points, matching his season-high.
GOALIE
Grade: B.
Matt Murray had a subpar showing during the Penguins’ 5-4 loss to Calgary Saturday, and was replaced by DeSmith for the third period of that game. DeSmith was back in goal against New York, although Murray’s history against the Rangers – he’s 8-0, including playoffs – would have made it easy to justify playing him. Nonetheless, coach Mike Sullivan stuck with his plan to split the weekend starts, and DeSmith responded with a solid performance, despite the number of pucks that got past him.
SPECIAL TEAMS
Grade: B-.
Lackluster penalty-killing has cost the Penguins points at times this season, but their work while shorthanded for a four-minute stretch in a 3-3 game is one of the main reasons they were able to take two from the Rangers. Late in the second period, Crosby was assessed a double-minor for high-sticking. The penalty-killers limited New York to three shots on goal during the four minutes that followed, and the Penguins went ahead for good shortly after Crosby left the penalty box. Although the Rangers had failed to convert on their previous 13 power-play chances at PPG Paints Arena, they capitalized on their first chance with the extra man. Actually, penalty-killer Teddy Blueger put the puck into his own net, as he deflected a cross-ice pass by New York’s Mats Zuccarello behind DeSmith. After breaking out of an extended slump Saturday by scoring on three of four opportunities against Calgary, the Penguins’ power play slipped back out of synch during its first three tries against the Rangers, generating only sporadic pressure. However, the No. 2 unit came through with 14 seconds remaining on the Penguins’ fourth and final chance with the extra man, as Pettersson took a cross-ice feed from Nick Bjugstad and one-timed a shot past New York goalie Alexandar Georgiev to give the Penguins a 3-1 lead.
COACHING
Grade: B.
Sullivan made an effective personnel adjustment during the game, moving Zach Aston-Reese from the fourth line to left wing on Malkin’s line and shifting Kessel to his natural position on the right side. (Bjugstad dropped to center on the third line after starting the game with Malkin and Kessel.) Sullivan made a pregame lineup change by scratching Garrett Wilson and plugging Dominik Simon into his spot on the fourth line with Cullen and Aston-Reese at the start of the game. Simon didn’t have a major impact – he was the only Penguins forward who didn’t record at least one shot on goal – but played just under 10 minutes and was credited with two hits. With the race for a playoff berth in the Eastern Conference tightening, this game reinforced the idea that Sullivan and his staff have a lot to clean up about the way the Penguins play in the defensive zone.
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.