(After every Penguins home game, the Post-Gazette will assess how each unit performed and what it means during the playoff push.)
FORWARDS
Grade: C+.
Gee, that guy wearing No. 71 for the Penguins looked a lot like Evgeni Malkin, which hasn’t been the case all that often in recent weeks. While his game was not without its blemishes –Michael Frolik scored the Flames’ second goal on a rebound after Malkin neglected to cover him near the net – Malkin, who was coming off a one-game suspension, looked considerably more focused and involved than he often has been lately.
He was rewarded with two goals – just his second and third in his past dozen games – in the third period, with both coming on power plays. Jake Guentzel, who had just one goal in the previous six games, scored his team-leading 28th of the season late in the first period deflecting a Justin Schultz shot out of the air and past Flames goalie Mike Smith. Although the Penguins outshot Calgary, 38-31, with 29 of those coming from centers and wingers, Guentzel’s goal – which came five seconds after a power play expired – was the only time they were able to beat Smith at even-strength.
DEFENSEMEN
Grade: C
Schultz, who returned to the lineup after missing 53 games because of a broken leg, drew a nice round of applause the first time he stepped onto the ice, and that wasn’t the only time he had the fans clapping. While there were times that he still seemed to be getting acclimated to the speed of the game, Schultz added a dimension to the No. 2 power play and picked up an assist on the Penguins’ first goal. In addition to that point, Schultz had a hit and a blocked shot while logging 17:12 of ice time.
Late in the first period, Marcus Pettersson dropped Calgary’s Austin Czarnik with a crushing hit at center ice, then had to defend himself against Flames forward Sam Bennett, who picked up a roughing minor – which actually should have been assessed for instigating – in addition to the fighting majors he and Pettersson received.
The Penguins could have used a little more of that kind of physicality around their net, because Calgary often had the better of play there. Kris Letang and Brian Dumoulin had much of the responsibility for trying to contain the Johnny Gaudreau-Sean Monahan-Elias Lindholm line, one of the league’s most productive units, and limited its members to a single assist, by Monahan. What’s more, Dumoulin tied Malkin and Crosby for the team lead with five shots.
GOALIES
Grade: D+
Matt Murray, who had stopped 88 of 90 shots during the previous two games, was replaced Casey DeSmith after allowing five goals on 24 shots during the first two periods. While Murray could not be blamed for either of Calgary’s first two goals – No. 1 came when a shot changed directions multiple times en route to the net, the second when Frolik beat Malkin to a loose puck near the net – the two that followed looked quite stoppable.
Czarnik scored the one that put Calgary up, 3-1, beating Murray with a wrist shot from the top of the left circle. While the puck might have glanced off defensemen Brian Dumoulin after Czarnik released it, Murray had an unobstructed view of the shot. Later in the second period, Travis Hamonic restored the Flames’ two-goal advantage when he threw a shot under the crossbar from inside the right circle, after Murray appeared to leave his feet a bit early, exposing the top part of the net. DeSmith was flawless during the final period, stopping all seven shots he faced.
Penguins coach Mike Sullivan discusses Saturday’s 5-4 loss to the Flames.
SPECIAL TEAMS
Grade: B+
The Penguins, who had scored on just one of their 21 power plays during the previous 10 games, were, to put it charitably, overdue to score a man-advantage goal and converted on three of their four opportunities. After Calgary snuffed the Penguins’ first try, the No. 1 unit got a measure of redemption – and a goal – during the Penguins’ next chance, as Sidney Crosby threw in a shot from along the goal line to the right of the net. The shot was impressive, but so was the patience and efficiency with which the Penguins moved the puck around after Flames penalty-killer Derek Ryan had lost his stick.
Malkin added two man-advantage goals in the final period, scoring one from the left side and the other on a slap shot from the top of the right circle. Calgary entered the game with a streak of 27 consecutive failed tries with the man-advantage when playing here, but that ended when Bennett swept in a shot late in the second period, while Zach Aston-Reese was serving a roughing minor. That was the 10th goal the Penguins had allowed in their past 31 shorthanded situations, but they killed the Flames’ second and third chances with the extra man.
COACHING
Grade: C
A case could have been made for Mike Sullivan to replace Murray earlier than he did, but doing so hardly was an obvious call, considering the level at which Murray has performed lately. Sullivan did some of his most significant work before the game, when he decided to sit winger Dominik Simon (one point in eight games) for the second game in a row, and scratched Tanner Pearson (one goal, one assist in 13 games) for the first time since he was acquired from Los Angeles three months ago.
Sullivan also moved Phil Kessel, who was goalless in seven games, onto left wing with Malkin and Nick Bjugstad, and made the correct call that Schultz was sharp enough to resume playing after his extended layoff.
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.