Jim Rutherford has shown himself to be a pretty astute judge of talent.
After all, he assembled a Stanley Cup-winning team for Carolina as general manager in 2006, then added the personnel pieces that helped to make the Penguins’ championships in 2016 and 2017 possible.
Mike Sullivan seems to have a knack for assessing the on-ice strengths and weaknesses of players, too, and has a couple of rings to prove it.
Likewise, Bill Guerin, who is Rutherford’s assistant, has earned a reputation for being able to evaluate talent. That’s a big part of the reason he’s widely regarded as a future GM in the NHL.
But before they moved into positions that showcased their ability to gauge players’ skills and project how they might fit on an effective forward line or defense pairing – and, ultimately, be part of a successful team – all three had lengthy playing careers in the NHL.
Guerin played for eight teams and is the only one of the trio to earn a championship as a player; he was part of New Jersey’s Cup-winning team in 1995 and joined the Penguins in 2009 for their run to the franchise’s third title.
Read More
Rutherford, meanwhile, spent most of his time in the league playing behind clubs that were average, at best, and Sullivan never made it past the first round in six playoff appearances with Calgary, Boston and Phoenix.
Here’s a look at what those three did during their playing days. And what, in retrospect, they would say about themselves in a scouting report:
BILL GUERIN
Position: Right winger
Height/weight: 6 feet 2, 220 pounds.
Stats: 429 goals, 427 assists in 1,263 games from 1991-92 to 2009-10.
Self assessment: “Competes. He has good outside speed. Will try to hit holes in the offensive zone to try to get shots and will play with a bit of an edge most nights. … And extremely good-looking.
“Can be sleepy on some nights. Most of his career, he was coachable. There were a couple of dark years where he was a little more difficult.”
MIKE SULLIVAN
Position: Center
Height/weight: 6 feet 2, 204 pounds.
Stats: 54 goals, 82 assists in 709 games from 1991-92 to 2001-02.
Self assessment: “Utility player. Penalty-killer. Faceoff guy. Fairly solid defensively. Can’t score.
“I was coachable. I had to be. I wouldn’t have played in the league if I wasn’t. I was one of those guys who was a role player, a utility guy, and tried to do what I could to help the team win.”
JIM RUTHERFORD
Position: Goaltender
Height/weight: 5 feet 8, 168 pounds.
Stats: 151-227-59 record, 3.66 goals-against average, .879 save percentage in 457 games from 1970-71 to 1982-83.
Self assessment: “I was told I wasn’t big enough to play, that I could never play professional hockey. When I got traded from Detroit the first time, I was too small, and got traded to Pittsburgh. When I got traded back to Detroit, I was the same size. For some reason, they didn’t think I was too small then. I didn’t play on great teams through my career, but figured a way to play 13 years in the league as a small goalie. I was just happy to make the NHL for one year, and ended up making it a 13-year career.
“My reflexes [were my greatest asset]. You had to be quick. With my size, (shooters) could see a lot of the net. My glove hand. Both my hands, actually. In those days, goalies used their hands a lot more. Goalies today are [shot]-blockers. Our equipment wasn’t very protective, so we had to use our hands so we could try to not get hit in the upper body, because when you did, you were hurting.”
Dave Molinari: Dmolinari@Post-Gazette.com and Twitter @MolinariPG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.