Hey, Clairton, Imani Christian and Jeannette. Put away your nickels, dimes and quarters. It turns out the WPIAL won’t be using a coin flip to determine your football playoff seedings after all.
After the final Friday night of the WPIAL regular season, the three teams were fit to be tied. Clairton, Imani Christian and Jeannette will tie for first place in the Class 1A Eastern Conference if Imani Christian beats Leechburg Saturday afternoon, a likely possibility, considering Imani Christian is 7-2 and Leechburg is 0-9. And if Leechburg loses by 10 points or more, then Imani Christian, Jeannette and Clairton would still be deadlocked after three different tiebreakers. An Imani Christian 10-point victory also is extremely likely, considering Leechburg has lost its nine games by an average of 28 points.
Under WPIAL playoff rules, when three or more teams are tied for playoff spots with identical records, head-to-head competition is the first tiebreaker. If they are all 1-1 against each other, a system called Gardner Points is applied to break the deadlock. If teams are still tied, the WPIAL tiebreaker points are then used, where points are earned based on comparative scores. If the teams are still deadlocked, the WPIAL resorts to a coin flip.
WPIAL executive director Tim O’Malley was fully aware of the situation. The league will decide playoff pairings and seedings Monday and the Clairton, Imani Christian and Jeannette situation had the WPIAL “flipping out.” O’Malley’s original idea was that three members of the WPIAL football committee would represent each school and flip a coin. The odd coin out would be given the No. 1 seed. The tie between the other two teams would be broken by their head-to-head outcome.
But O’Malley figured out Saturday there is no need for the coin flip. The only reason the coin flip would have been needed was to determine what team would get a home game in the first round of the playoffs. But all three teams would get a home game no matter who won the coin flip. The WPIAL football committee would’ve subjectively seeded the teams, no matter the outcome of the coin flip.
“They all have the same record [in conference play], they are all first-place teams and they will all three get first-place championship plaques Monday night,” said O’Malley. “Their place in the bracket and the seedings will be determined by the committee anyway, so there is no need for a coin flip. There would’ve been a need for a coin flip if only one or two of those teams were getting a home game.”
Read More
Some might say why would the WPIAL have a system where a coin flip might determine a playoff spot? Well, the league does have three different ways to break ties and if they are exhausted, then what?
A coin flip is not totally new, either. Back in 2002, Upper St. Clair, McKeesport and Canon-McMillan tied for first place in the Quad West Conference of Class 4A. Only the top two teams got home games in the first round. Upper St. Clair got first place with more Gardner Points. That left McKeesport and Canon-McMillan in a tie for second. Back then, head-to-head competition wasn’t used, and McKeesport and Canon-McMillan were tied in Gardner Points and also tiebreaker points. So a coin flip was needed.
McKeesport won the coin flip and second place, even though it lost to Canon-McMillan in the regular season.
Going back to the present situation, it will be interesting to see how the WPIAL seeds Imani Christian, Clairton and Jeannette. They are all 1-1 against each other. Jeannette had an impressive victory at Imani Christian, but a week later, Imani Christian won at Clairton, even though Imani Christian was without five players who were ineligible. Then Friday night, Jeannette took an undefeated record to Clairton and was trounced, 40-6.
If I had a vote for the Class 1A bracket overall, I’d put California No. 1. Yes, California is from the much-maligned Tri-County South. But this team is undefeated and the Trojans proved they are legit when they won at Imani Christian earlier this season. I’d put Imani Christian as the No. 2 overall, Clairton No. 3 and Jeannette fourth. Although Clairton is playing well now, you can’t take away the fact that the Bears lost at home to a short-handed Imani Christian team. And Clairton’s impressive win against Jeannette should move Clairton ahead of Jeannette.
But at least coins won’t determine the seedings.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.