Wedged into the gritty University of Pennsylvania campus at 33rd and Spruce in West Philadelphia, Franklin Field stood ready, 50 years ago this very Sunday, to present one of the most forgettable events in its distinguished history.
The place had already loomed there for 70 years, and it endures even today as the home of Penn Quakers football, but on this day, Dec. 11, 1966, the venue that once saw Franklin Delano Roosevelt accept his party’s nomination for President of the United States would be staging something far less momentous, far less historic, far less hopeful, far less inspiring.
Except to me.
It was the Philadelphia Eagles against the Cleveland Browns, two teams that could not get out of each other’s way on that day or on precious few to come. The Browns would go forth from 1966 to post all of 17 winning seasons in the next 50 years, the Eagles only 22, but to me, that sloppy 33-21 Eagles victory was a thing of unrelenting wonder. It was the first NFL game I saw in person.
I’d arrived after a morning walkthrough my father conducted at the cradle of liberty – Independence Hall, Liberty Bell, etc – followed by a brisk 2½ mile walk across town to find pro football in all its burgeoning glory. At least to me. There were six Hall of Famers on the field – Paul Warfield, Lou Groza, Leroy Kelly, Bob Brown, Ollie Matson, Jim Ringo, and there were Timmy Brown and Pete Retzlaff and Frank Ryan and Gary Collins, and there was someone named Al Nelson returning a field goal a then-record 100 yards for an Eagles touchdown.
Even to the jaded Philly audience doing its dark diligence (one guy around us barked, “Now it’s time for our famous roughing-the-kicker play!”) it was clear the NFL as an entertainment product was about to explode.
Read More
Only six years earlier, the league’s championship game between the Eagles and Vince Lombardi’s Packers had been played on the same field on a Monday afternoon. Because Sunday was Christmas, and you don’t play football on Christmas, right? You’d have to have some nerve – what ego! – to play on Christmas.
By 1966 though, the NFL was catching fire across the sportscape and the culture. It would soon have the Super Bowl and a seemingly inexhaustible narrative of iconic moments and star players who would rocket it to unimaginable riches. Its hundreds of enduring heroes would deliver the Immaculate Reception and The Catch and The Drive and the Motor City Miracle and whatever else an insatiable TV audience required.
Until it didn’t.
Which is now.
“Maybe we’ve become oversaturated with it,” Steelers All-Pro guard David DeCastro was saying this week. “Maybe there’s so much NFL, all the games, the Thursday games, all the post-season stuff, all the [scouting] combine stuff, all of this delving into it to find out what the secret is.”
What about the wonder of it; that’s what I was asking. Where has the wonder gone?
“You kind of lose [the wonder] with all that,” he said.
The dip in interest in the NFL is real, real and irreversible some will tell you. The league insists this is cyclical, just as it insisted that after the rhetorical riot known as the 2016 election had its conclusion TV ratings would rise again. That’s been true only episodically. Generally, ratings remain off about 10 percent, and by 20 percent or more for Monday Night Football and its troubled offspring, Thursday Night Football.
Ratings for last Sunday’s promising Steelers-Giants matchup were down 11 percent from the same spot last year. (The Steelers-Colts Thanksgiving night show was off 27 percent from last season’s holiday prime timer.) Ratings for Detroit at New Orleans were off 21 percent. The Cowboys and Vikings earned a 22 percent bump up for Thursday Night Football, but overall ratings for Week 13, four weeks after the election, were down nine percent according to Sports Media Watch. Ratings for regional action in Week 10, days after the election, were off 33 percent.
Who could have foreseen this?
A Mr. Mark Cuban for one.
It was the maverick Dallas Mavericks owner who in 2014 barked, “Just watch; pigs get fat, hogs get slaughtered. When you try to take it too far, people turn the other way. ... When you’ve got a good thing and you get greedy; it always, always, always, always turns on you. That’s Rule No. 1 of business.”
Cuban, I learned this week, takes no satisfaction in the NFL’s slippage. As an innovative sports executive, he hopes earnestly to learn from it, but he’s seen the problems expand rather than abate.
“All sports have an intrinsic issue,” Cuban said via e-mail. “When we were kids, we lived for sports on TV. We read newspapers. Our teams were a religion. Today, kids have a screen in their hands and they are watching more Minecraft videos than games. I can’t drag my kids to a football, hockey or baseball game without bribing them. Obviously basketball is a little different in our household.
“All sports have to figure out how to get kids to live sports the way their parents do. Football has the additional problem of concussions. They haven’t and won’t solve the problem. Players are walking away from their game and parents are not allowing their kids to play beyond flag football.
“It’s a difficult calculus we all must face, but I truly believe the NFL has the worst of it.”
Surprisingly, when people who identified themselves as solid NFL fans responded to a Yahoo/YouGov poll last month, 40 percent said they were watching less because of the national anthem protests begun in the preseason by San Francisco 49ers quarterback Colin Kaepernick, later a conspicuous non-voter.
But that, too, was not a surprise to everyone.
“I think if someone doesn’t like what someone’s doing, they’re not gonna watch it,” DeCastro said. “Why would they? If someone doesn’t like someone kneeling for the national anthem, if they’re a patriot or something and maybe they feel like that message is being taken the wrong way, even though someone’s not trying do that message, why would they watch the NFL? See what I mean?”
DeCastro has a bigger issue with the venomous climate around the issue, and seemingly any issue, than with the issue itself.
“I think some people should be football players and worry about playing football,” said the thoughtful Stanford grad. “You’ve got 16 games a year to play football. You can’t win with politics. Everybody’s got an opinion and the problem with this country is, you can’t have a conversation anymore without someone saying you’re such-and-such and such-and-such.
“I don’t want to get into it, and this is just an example of what I’m talking about. Me just even going into that or answering that question is an example. Everybody’s got an opinion, but you’ve got to respect people in this world. It’s sad. I don’t know if it’s the media dividing this country or making it worse than it seems, but it’s just like you can’t say anything anymore without someone jumping down your throat, and that’s sad.”
By now just about everyone’s been over the familiar laundry list of plausible factors that have forced the NFL past its tipping point of likability: too many concussions, too many injuries, too many penalties, too many replay delays, too many commercials, too many show boaters, too many dreary matchups, too much exposure, and, really, too many excesses to bother extending this sentence any further.
The league has brought most of this upon itself by perpetually seeking new revenue streams for an industry that was already swimming in cash, but the most pernicious might be its relationship with fantasy players, who now number some 80 million. Fantasy football has changed the reason people watch games, which is pretty fundamental. A fantasy stats junkie can’t sit still for a three-hour telecast. They don’t need a 12-play drive capped by a fabulous Dak Prescott-to-Dez Bryant connection; they need a data dealer. Now.
“It could just be that we have so many different outlets that we’re draining the product,” Steelers defense end Cam Heyward said the other day. “But I still think the drama in the playoffs is unmatched by anything because it’s single elimination. What other sports do that? You don’t get that in hockey or baseball or basketball. In football you get one chance to prove yourself. It’s unmatched by any other sport.”
We’ve all known, some of us for 50 years or more, that there’s something very special about the NFL’s brand of spectacle, yet it seems the more we look at it, the harder that is to find.
Correction (posted Dec. 11, 2016): An earlier version of this column had an incorrect first name for Gary Collins.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.