The night the Penguins won the Stanley Cup for the first time — May 25, 1991, to be exact — they arrived home at the old Pittsburgh International Airport, and former general manager Craig Patrick informed everyone that they couldn’t get to their cars.

So they chartered a few school buses on a 90-degree night and took the back way, through the woods, to Sewickley. On the way, a woman got the driver’s attention on the loud and crowded bus, asked him to pull over and ran to the edge of the woods to go to the bathroom.

“Next thing you know,” Mike Lange remembered during the 50 Years of Hockey in Pittsburgh presented by KeyBank and the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette event Monday night at the Heinz History Center, “every male on that bus was doing the same thing.”

That story was one of many shared by the four-person panel of Lange, president/CEO David Morehouse, current general manager Jim Rutherford and franchise patriarch Eddie Johnston before about 700 fans on the fifth floor on Smallman Street.

Advertise with us

It drew plenty of laughs on a night filled not only with insight but humor as well.

David Shribman, the executive editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, served as the moderator of the event and combined with Rutherford to set the tone early when he introduced the GM as the architect of the Penguins fourth Stanley Cup-winning team … “and the fifth.”

Shribman then asked Rutherford whom the Penguins would beat in the Stanley Cup final this year. “Whoever we play,” Rutherford shot back.

Some early conversation revolved around fighting in today’s NHL, how it was different from when Rutherford and Johnston played and its future.

“When you look at the best events in hockey — Olympics, World Cup — you don’t have any fighting in those events,” Rutherford said. “Even when you get to the Stanley Cup final, you don’t have fighting. I don’t think we need it.”

Advertise with us

Many jokes involved Johnston’s penchant for having a good time, the majority perpetuated by Johnston himself.

When Johnston played in Boston and Bobby Orr — more on Orr shortly — was a rookie, Johnston had Orr serve as his designated driver.

“I used to frequent the bars … not that I’ve changed now,” Johnston said. “He would drive me down there, and two or three weeks into his career, I bought him a chauffeur’s hat. I had the best player in the game driving me around.”

The best player of all time, actually.

The panelists agreed that Orr transformed the game in such a way that he is the greatest they had ever seen, although Morehouse tried to say Mario Lemieux three times when asked for his top three before he was reminded who signs his paychecks.

Advertise with us

Johnston put Lemieux and Jean Beliveau next. Rutherford and Lange split second and third with Lemieux and Wayne Gretzky.

Johnston drew more laughs when he recalled what it was like playing with Orr.

“I used to see him before the game and tell him I’d see him again after,” Johnston recalled. “With him on our team, we didn’t spend too much time in our own end.”

Injuries and taking pucks to the face was another central theme with the two goalies.

Rutherford recalled a minute after wearing a mask for the first time getting hit in the mouth, losing four teeth and needing 43 stitches. For Johnston, it was broken toes, a broken collarbone, six weeks in a coma, four broken noses and having to have his ear sewn back on.

Advertise with us

In more recent talk, Morehouse admitted that the Penguins were extremely close to bolting for Kansas City. “We would not have a hockey team here if we had stayed in the old building.”

Ron Francis was anointed the most underrated player in franchise history, with Mark Recchi a close second.

To equal Lange’s side-of-the-road story, Rutherford told one about a poor first period at the old Boston Garden. He slammed the door to the area of the dressing room for the goalies, and it locked behind him. “As luck would have it, I wish it would have stayed locked,” Rutherford said of his struggles in that game.

Morehouse remembered a double-fisting Hal Gill in a much-too-small fountain at Lemieux’s place after the last Cup win.

Hockey-wise, Rutherford didn’t hold back when asked about the point of morning skates.

Advertise with us

“There isn’t one,” he said.

Mike Sullivan, of course, was a topic of conversation.

Rutherford: “It didn’t matter whether it was our best or worst player, he was going to hold their feet to the fire. He took control of the team.”

Lange reminisced a little about the Civic Arena, how he wished its shape would have transferred to the new place and the words scribbled on the wall in its upper-reaches.

Someone suggested “For a good time, call Eddie Johnston” was on there.

Advertise with us

“They could do that,” Johnston said.

Johnston and the others definitely delivered a good time during this one.

Jason Mackey: jmackey@post-gazette.com..