CHARLOTTE, N.C. — When the ACC expanded to 15 teams a couple of years ago, the hope was that it would become the best men’s basketball conference in Division I. A great measure of that is the number of teams that reach the NCAA tournament.
The Big East Conference, before it was broken up, had become that league when finishing in the top half almost assuredly meant a trip to the NCAA tournament. One year the Big East had 11 teams earn bids.
That hasn’t happened in the ACC, however, as the league has earned only six bids in the past two seasons. That has left some coaches wondering if it is going to be too difficult to climb from the bottom-half of the league into an NCAA contender.
One idea that has been floated around the league among coaches and administrators is changing the conference schedule to try to increase the chances of more teams making the NCAA tournament.
But with 15 teams and each having different agendas, the issue has become finding some sort of consensus as to what is the best course of action for the conference schedule. The answer more and more seems to be to go from 18 conference games to 20.
ACC commissioner John Swofford addressed this and many other subjects in his annual “state of the conference” address as a part of ACC Operation Basketball preseason media day at the Ritz-Carlton Hotel.
“This league is brutally competitive,” Swofford said. “As we look at our ACC basketball schedules, should we consider playing more conference games? Would that enhance players’ experiences while they are in the Atlantic Coast Conference?
“It would create a more balanced schedule, but on the other hand, how would it affect the number of teams selected from our league to NCAA tournament play? Would it help us or would it hinder us?”
Swofford said that it isn’t clear whether a 20-game conference schedule is coming or not, but it seems to be moving in that direction and he believes there are some real benefits to it.
Coaches are divided on whether it is good or bad to play more conference games and the issue of how to achieve a balanced schedule with 15 teams is not going away no matter what is done.
Notre Dame coach Mike Brey is a big advocate for the 20-game schedule because he believes it will increase the Ratings Percentage Index (RPI) of each team and strengthen the middle and bottom of the conference.
He said that playing each other more would keep the quality wins within the conference and give teams from other conferences less opportunities to knock off the top of the league.
“When we went from 16 to 18 league games in the Big East, it mixed the RPI of the league more,” Brey said. “It gave another bubble team yet another shot at a “lock” team in February or March in order to try and get in. I firmly believe that, plus, not having permanent repeat opponents was based on trying to get as many teams in the tournament as possible.”
Brey said that when they were in the Big East and building the Irish, the idea of getting into the top five or six in order to secure an NCAA tournament bid seemed near impossible, but when the league started getting eight or nine it became more realistic.
“I’d say to myself, well, I just have to finish eighth or ninth, that’s definitely doable,” Brey said. “It just gives guys more hope. And we have such great inventory, let’s give as much of it to TV as possible and the other thing is we don’t need to be giving the Big East and the Big Ten that many shots at us.”
The idea of more conference games could work for the ACC but it also could backfire as several coaches said it means the teams in the league will just beat up on each other.
Miami coach Jim Larranaga said that if the ACC wants more games on television — and he believes that is the goal — then they should have more conference games but if they want more teams in the NCAA tournament they should actually have less conference games. “If the primary goal is to get more teams in the NCAA tournament, then we should be talking about doing the opposite. You’d want your conference teams to beat up on non-conference opponents to show how dominating of a league we have.”
Pitt coach Jamie Dixon said there is no way to make a fair and balanced schedule unless the ACC were to go to divisions. Then the ACC would need to add a 16th member and nobody wants that. He said divisions aren’t the answer either, and the problem with adding two more conference games is it would mean that the conference likely would have to end the Big Ten-ACC Challenge. It also means teams would have even less flexibility in scheduling.
“More conference games comes down to TV but I can see the value in it, but there will have to be some give and take to make it work,” he said. “We want to separate ourselves. We keep going around telling everyone we are the best conference so maybe we should just play more in-house games.”
Dixon said the one idea he hates — but momentum is building for — is that teams don’t have their “rival” games (teams in a home-and-home format) set in stone. Instead, the home-and-home opponents would be mixed and matched each year to create the best matchups.
Pitt fans can count on games against Syracuse and Louisville (the Panthers’ two repeat opponents) at home each year and is something they can look forward to. But a lot of coaches said it isn’t fair the way that it is now.
“What they should do, they won’t do — you should play everyone the same over a period of time,” Syracuse coach Jim Boeheim said. “Throw all rivalries out. You should play the same schedule over a 10-year period as everyone else. I don’t care that North Carolina has always played Duke [twice a year], that’s too bad.
“Why shouldn’t Georgia Tech fans get to see North Carolina the same number of times? That’s the fairest way — they made this decision to expand to [15] teams so they should also understand to be fair, everyone should play the same number of games against each other over a period of time.”
Paul Zeise: pzeise@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1720 and Twitter @paulzeise.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.