Steven Winberg, assistant secretary for fossil energy at the U.S. Department of Energy, says the country is at a crossroads.
“We can decide we’re going to leave coal in the ground or we can say that technology is the solution to any emission problems,” he said. “So, we have decided we’re going to begin the process of building new (coal) generation.”
Mr. Winberg was referring to a request for information that DOE sent out earlier this year titled: “Coal-Based Power Plants of the Future.” These would be highly efficient, small(ish) powerplants, between 50 megawatts and 350 megawatts, “and economical for both international and domestic power generation.”
The request, which would eventually culminate in a pilot plant, has drawn dozens of company responses, which the government is “digesting,” Mr. Winberg said.
Speaking Friday to a group of mostly graduate students at the University of Pittsburgh’s Swanson School of Engineering, Mr. Winberg said it’s coal, not “sexy” renewables, that powers the economy and will for years to come.
When Paul Cohen, founding dean and professor at Pitt’s School of Computing and Information, asked whether there is an overall energy policy in the U.S., Mr. Winberg said, “No.”
“Shouldn’t there be?” Mr. Cohen wondered.
“I don’t think so.”
The fuel mix in the United States is so diverse, Mr. Winberg said, that “I don’t think that we’re at a point where we can actually have a national energy policy.”
Nor is there a need for one, he added.
“I don’t think the federal government ought to be setting policy,” Mr. Winberg said. That should be up to the states and the individual grid operators. “I think that’s what moves technology forward.”
Earlier this week, e-mails between Mr. Winberg and other DOE and National Energy Technology Laboratory officials were made public, showing them considering ways to stress the contribution of coal-fired power plants to the grid and warn of reliability problems if those plants retire.
The emails were obtained by the environmental group Sierra Club through a public records request.
They chronicle the preparation of a March report about the “bomb cyclone,” a vicious cold snap of a few weeks around the turn of the year.
Mr. Winberg was already thinking about the role of coal in the energy grid days after the weather began to temper when he visited NETL’s South Hills location. He called it the “mainstay for electricity generation” and said “we saw (it) in a very real way a week and a half ago when we were in the bomb cyclone.”
NETL’s March report was produced in the context of DOE’s push to provide subsidies for coal and nuclear plants in the name of reliability and resilience. Many such plants have either announced plans to retire or have gone dark, largely because they couldn’t compete against the low cost of natural gas.
So far, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission has resisted requiring such subsidies. Robert Powelson, the former Pennsylvania public utility commissioner who was nominated to the FERC in May 2017, was particularly blunt about his reluctance to interfere in power markets.
On Jan. 31, Mr. Powelson discussed the bomb cyclone through a different lens, saying, “It wasn’t coal plants that saved the day. It was 1950s vintage oil burners,” a reference to the high burn of fuel oil in the Northeast during that time.
But he was speaking to a group of oil and gas companies at Hart Energy’s Marcellus-Utica Midstream conference in Pittsburgh, where he also indicated that FERC wasn’t inclined to push for coal subsidies.
In June, Mr. Powelson announced he would leave FERC this month to head a trade association for water utilities.
In January, FERC chairman Kevin McIntyre told a U.S. Senate committee that the nation’s grids “performed relatively well” during the bomb cyclone, without giving the kind of credit to coal that DOE and NETL officials would have liked, according to the newly public e-mails.
Reports from grid operators, such as PJM Interconnection, which manages electricity for 13 states including Pennsylvania, hit similar notes.
"PJM has at least admitted that coal was necessary. FERC has not,” Peter Balash, director of NETL’s Office of Strategic Analysis and Planning and a co-author of the March report, wrote in an e-mail to Mr. Winberg in February. “Our report will rebut FERC.”
Asked about the e-mails on Friday, Mr. Winberg said: “The effort isn’t to prop up coal plants or nuclear plants.”
“But there is a very real national security issue, both cyber and physical” to be considered, he warned.
In the event of an attack on the infrastructure, “the more generation we have, the better we are able to recover.”
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.