A few years ago, Joe Raposky was in the middle of negotiating an oil and gas lease with EQT Corp. when he ran into his friend and neighbor William Mattes. Mr. Mattes had also been approached by EQT, he said, about signing off on gas storage rights.

What gas storage? Mr. Raposky asked.

The two men had been aware of the Finleyville gas storage field in the area but both thought it didn’t reach their properties.

Joe Raposky at his home Wednesday in Finleyville. (Jessie Wardarski / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Turns out it was actually below their feet, Mr. Mattes explained. The maps that prove that came from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, he said.

Advertise with us

So Mr. Raposky called FERC, and at his next meeting with EQT there were six company representatives ready to bundle his oil and gas lease with an easement that allows gas storage.

Except Mr. Raposky wanted more than what was on the table.

Read More

“I told [an EQT attorney] I wanted paid for the gas they took,” he said. “I want free gas, and I want paid for unjust enrichment and violation of my Fifth Amendment rights and trespass. I read those off to him. And then I said I want these back payments back to 2007.”

Why 2007?

“I said that’s what I can prove.”

Advertise with us

‘This could get a lot bigger’

The Finleyville storage field — some 2,630 feet under the surface — is one of EQT’s smallest and the company’s oldest. It was established in 1934, back when Equitable Gas was a division of George Westinghouse’ Philadelphia Co. utility.

According to a state Department of Environmental Protection fact sheet, there are about 60 gas storage fields in Pennsylvania, spread across 26 counties.

Most are depleted oil and gas reservoirs: what made them good at producing gas also makes them suitable for storing it, said Alan Stagg, an economic geologist and president of West Virginia-based Stagg Resource Consultants Inc.

Homeowner Joe Raposky walks through his backyard Wednesday in Finleyville. (Jessie Wardarski / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

In defining a storage field, geologists look at how porous the rock is and how those pores connect to one another. That informs how much gas can be stored and at what pressure. They also look at well records to determine which ones produced gas and which were dry. That helps establish the boundaries of the reservoir.

Advertise with us

Once a field has a shape, the company developing it puts a buffer zone around it, Mr. Stagg said, in case the gas migrates or to ensure that other earth-penetrating activity doesn’t interfere with the integrity of the field.

“In theory, they should get easements for both the field and buffer zone,” he said.

According to the 2012 map that EQT supplied to FERC, Mr. Mattes’ property appears to be within the field while Mr. Raposky’s looks to be within the buffer zone.

It might not have always been that way.

According to earlier maps of the field, which Mr. Raposky found among files at the Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection, the extent of it was much smaller — about a third of the current size. It could be that the gas migrated to expand the field or that better measurement techniques now have defined the boundaries more accurately.

Advertise with us

In any case, by the time Mr. Raposky sat down with those six EQT representatives, he had seen the bigger footprint and he was negotiating not just for himself but for a group of 30 landowners in the area.

If the company refused to settle the gas storage issue with this group, Mr. Raposky said, he’d get others on board.

“This could get a lot bigger,” he threatened.

When EQT wouldn’t budge on the back pay, Mr. Raposky started knocking on doors. He found people who lived above the Bunola storage field across the Monongahela River, and the Tepe field to the north.

He appeared before Union Township supervisors last August to let his grievance with EQT be known and offered his experience to others in the same predicament. With dozens of landowners in tow, Mr. Raposky called an Indiana-based eminent domain lawyer.

Advertise with us

For months, attorney Jordan Walker went back and forth with EQT asking the company for proof that it was allowed to store gas under its clients’ land. The bulk of what he got were copies of recent oil and gas production leases, some of which also have gas storage clauses, he said.

Those leases aren’t retroactive, Mr. Walker said. “My response was this had absolutely nothing to do with [the past].”

On July 30, the landowners filed a lawsuit against EQT alleging, among other things trespass and unjust enrichment — the fighting words that Mr. Raposky tossed at the company more than a year ago.

The complaint has more than 100 landowners in Allegheny and Washington counties on board.

“I’m hoping it ends up being a jury trial,” Mr. Raposky said. “I have so much information.”

Advertise with us

EQT said it doesn’t comment on litigation.

‘Just compensation’

Natural gas storage fields fall under the jurisdiction of FERC, which issues certificates of public convenience and necessity to such projects.

Those certificates come with the right for a company to use eminent domain to take land where it can not negotiate easements. However, the company is required to have tried to negotiate those easements and, even after a successful eminent domain proceeding, must compensate the reticent landowners at a fair price.

The process for certifying EQT’s storage fields was less direct.

Advertise with us

Some were established before the laws governing the process were enacted. For several, including the Finleyville storage field, FERC could find no certificates at all.

By the mid-aughts, EQT and FERC sought to make the fields official. After two years of measurements, EQT presented to FERC maps and data on 14 storage fields and the federal agency certified them all in 2007. The maps weren’t made public until five years later.

In 2014, EQT Midstream Partners, a master limited partnership that EQT spun out to operate gas transportation and storage assets, stated in a securities filing, “There are lands within the partnership’s storage pools as to which it does not currently have real property rights.” It was in the process of securing these rights, the company said.

Between 2009 and the end of 2013, the document said EQT got the rights to 18,576 acres out of a total 46,452 acres and said it “expects to acquire the remainder within the next three years.” It budgeted $6 million for the upcoming effort.

When asked this week if the company reached its target, EQT did not respond.

Advertise with us

Across the border in Ohio, Columbia Gas Transmission had spent years in litigation with a class of hundreds of landowners who claimed that the company didn’t have easements to store gas under their properties and that they were owed backpay.

Columbia didn’t argue the first point and filed an eminent domain claim against all of the landowners’ properties. The case became about what constitutes fair compensation and, even veered into whether the company was obligated under the Natural Gas Act to to negotiate easement payments in “good faith” (the court found that it was not).

A group of Ohio landowners said that in addition to compensating them for the use of their properties going back to 1959 — the creation of the storage field — Columbia owes them additional damages for trespass and unjust enrichment, and for interfering with their ability to extract gas from their property.

The claims are remarkably similar to those being made in the current EQT suit.

The U.S. District Court in the northern district of Ohio ruled in February that Columbia didn’t owe them any additional payments beyond “just compensation” for the easements that weren’t in place since the landowners bought their properties.

Advertise with us

As far as trespassing, the court said, the landowners couldn’t prove that it was malicious.

Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.

Correction, posted Aug. 10, 2018: A reference to the location of the Bunola storage field has been corrected.