Pennsylvania regulators halted construction of the Mariner East 2 pipeline after a pattern of “egregious and willful violations” that has trailed the year-old project.
The move on Wednesday followed months of back and forth between the state Department of Environmental Protection, environmental groups, and Sunoco Logistics, the company building the $2.5 billion twin natural gas liquids pipelines across 17 counties in Pennsylvania.
The DEP said nothing short of halting construction would shake Sunoco’s demonstrated “lack of ability or intention to comply” with state laws that safeguard commonwealth land and waterways.
Since permits were issued in February 2017, Sunoco has racked up dozens of violations for spills of drilling mud along its path, some flowing into sensitive streams and others clouding water supplies for nearby residents.
Between May and September last year, the DEP chronicled more than 30 spills in southwestern Pennsylvania — 2 in Allegheny County, 10 in Washington and 18 in Westmoreland.
The DEP also documented numerous instances of Sunoco not following conditions of its permits.
Read More
For example, on several occasions, including one in Washington County, Sunoco drilled an underground tunnel for its pipeline where it had been given a permit to lay the pipe in a trench on the surface. The practice is called horizontal directional drilling and is often used to bore under wetlands, streams, and roads so as to not disturb the surface.
The company cannot decide to change its drilling technique without first getting approval from the DEP.

Spills of drilling mud -— mixture of clay and water — are “kind of an expected thing in horizontal directional drilling,” said Neil Shader, a spokesperson for the DEP, so much so that an application for a pipeline like this includes a section asking companies about their response plans for such spills.
But Sunoco’s spills were more frequent and more polluting than would be expected, Mr. Shader said. That, “as well as a pattern of sloppy contractor work” led to the DEP’s action on Wednesday, he said.
This isn’t the first time that construction on the pipeline has been suspended. In the summer, an Environmental Hearing Board judge ordered a halt of horizontal directional drilling after Sunoco impacted drinking water supplies in southwestern Pennsylvania.
The only other major natural gas pipeline under construction in Pennsylvania right now — Williams’ Atlantic Sunrise line that broke ground in September — has two notices of violation to date, Mr. Shader noted for comparison.
Sunoco’s parent company Energy Transfer Partners issued a brief statement expressing confidence that work on the project will restart promptly and reiterating its “commitment to the highest levels of construction expertise and our dedication to preserving and protecting the environment in which we conduct our work.”
The company declined to answer questions about the frequency of its violations or whether any contractors have been disciplined as a result.
Environmental activists and pipeline opponents who have organized to resist the project and document its faults struck a tone somewhere between “I told you so” and “not enough.”
Karen Feridun, founder of the anti-fracking group Berks Gas Truth, called the DEP’s order “welcome news, but it is far from being the solution communities across the state have needed and have sought.”
She vowed to continue the fight until this project “and the other unnecessary and dangerous infrastructure projects planned for Berks County” are canceled.
Food and Water Watch, a Washington, D.C.-based environmental group, sent a statement headlined, “Gov. [Tom] Wolf bows to public pressure.” It then asked the governor to suspend the project all together.
“The movement to stop the pipeline will be using this temporary halt to build the power we know we’ll need to protect communities from Mariner East once and for all,” promised Sam Rubin, an organizer with the group.
The Mariner East 2 pipeline is already behind schedule — its in-service date was pushed from last year to the second quarter of 2018 — and the DEP’s action could add months to the delay.
The agency has given Sunoco 30 days to submit documents that would essentially show how it plans to follow the rules going forward. The DEP would then need to review those plans. At this time, there’s no timeline for that review, said Mr. Shader said.
Mariner East 2, along with Atlantic Sunrise and several other major pipelines snaking the Appalachian region to capitalize on the glut of oil and gas being slurped out of the ground here, has become a rallying cry for opponents of fossil fuel development.
Where 10 years ago, much of the resistance was focused on fighting fracking and trying to scuttle plans for individual wells, activists have moved downstream — figuring that blocking a pipeline effectively chokes off the wells it would service and the plants it would supply.
The Mariner East 2 project was designed to carry ethane, butane and propane to the Philadelphia region. The footprint provided opponents an opportunity to fan out their efforts across the state and focus resistance efforts in particularly receptive areas — the Philadelphia suburbs have been particularly bothered by the development.
But what also helped is the data. The Mariner East 2 project is the first for which detailed locations were made public, allowing Pittsburgh-based nonprofit FracTracker Alliance to map the entire route.
FracTracker’s work on the project began before the permit was issued, overlaying its proposed path with known waterways and wetlands. As information about violations became available, the organization plopped the spills on to a map. Then it showed how many schools were within a blast radius of the pipeline, as calculated by a friendly engineer.
That’s when activism really took off, said Kirk Jalbert, who makes the maps at FracTracker.
Yard signs proclaiming a property to be within the blast radius began to appear.
Advocates started to print out FracTracker’s maps and bring them along to township meetings and hand them out during door-to-door blitzes. They used them as the backdrop for GoFundMe campaigns that raised money to hire engineers and lawyers to help residents fight the pipeline.
People in different parts of the state along the pipeline’s path kept in touch through Facebook and listserves that kept pace with where spills were reported, whose water was impacted, and which politicians were starting to respond to pressure.
Just before Christmas when the DEP sent Sunoco a letter referencing drinking water compaints in Cumberland County, pipeline opponents felt the momentum building.
They organized a campaign to indundate phone lines in Harrisburg, suggesting a script to convince Gov. Tom Wolf to stop the pipeline.
The action did not stop with the DEP’s order on Wednesday. Within hours, an activist called P.k. Ditty streamed on Facebook Live a tour of Sunoco’s pipeline construction sites to ensure work had stopped as ordered.
“I have my DEP notice here to hand to the foreman if we need to,” P.k. Ditty said in the video. “This is a great time to keep these guys accountable.”
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.