The Department of Energy has thrown a lifeline to the nation’s struggling nuclear and coal power plants claiming that without them, the U.S. is headed for blackouts.
That move would directly benefit a number of large power plants in Pennsylvania, including the Beaver Valley nuclear station and the Bruce Mansfield coal power plant, both in Beaver County, as well as Homer City Generation in Indiana County. All have been under pressure from cheap natural gas, and while Homer City has tenuously emerged from bankruptcy, Bruce Mansfield and Beaver Valley are in danger of plunging into it.
The DOE instructed the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission — an independent agency whose commissioners are appointed by the president and which recently regained a quorum with two nominations from President Donald Trump — to pass a rule that would establish tariffs allowing eligible plants to recover their costs and realize a “fair rate of return.”
The agency says eligible plants would have 90 days of fuel on site, making then fuel-secure resources. Given that natural gas is delivered by pipeline at the time it’s burned and not stored on site, this rule would disadvantage the growing oil and gas industry.
Swiftly, the administration’s usual allies in oil and gas industry took notice.
“We need to be careful that government doesn’t put its thumb on the scale,” said Marty Durbin, executive vice president and chief strategy officer of the American Petroleum Institute, an industry trade organization. “Markets play an important role in determining energy sources because markets reward innovation, spur efficiency, lower prices and work to benefit consumers.”
The National Gas Supply Association said it was “dismayed” by Department of Energy’s move and derided the “market distortions and fuel preferences” inherent in it.
But the announcement wasn’t a shock to those in the coal industry.
At Platt’s Coal Marketing days, a coal conference held Downtown on Tuesday, talk of federal intervention for coal power plants was anticipated and celebrated.
Bob Simons, a partner at the Reed Smith law firm, even called out the exact mechanism specified in DOE’s announcement Friday — the Federal Power Act — saying it might be used to help FirstEnergy’s coal plants in Pennsylvania.
Ohio-based FirstEnergy has been trying to transition to a model where all of its businesses rely on guaranteed rates from customers.
In Pennsylvania, FirstEnergy’s plants are not subject to the regulated model and are therefore competing with cheap natural gas and other market forces. For several years, the company has been pushing for the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission to reward coal and nuclear plants for their ability to store fuel on site.
The company’s CEO Chuck Jones issued a statement Friday praising Secretary Rick Perry and the Department of Energy “for recognizing the importance of a reliable, resilient electric grid for American families and our nation's economy.
“We look forward to final action by the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission as soon as possible," he said.
DOE’s timeline for the proposed regulation is swift: It is telling the FERC to act within 60 days.
Even more hurried is the timeline for regional grid operators like Valley Forge-based PJM Interconnection, which coordinates the flow of electricity to 13 states including Pennsylvania, and sets the market structure for its participants.
PJM has 15 days from the adoption of the final rule to say how it will comply.
“That would be rather fast,” was the only comment that Ray Dotter, a spokesperson for PJM could muster on Friday. “We’ve only just started reading and trying to understand.”
DOE said it is basing its rule on a 60-day study it commissioned earlier this year to evaluate the impact that coal and nuclear retirements will have on reliability.
Friday’s rule proposal called coal and nuclear plants “indispensable to the resilience of our electric grid — and therefore indispensable for our economic and national security.
“It is time for the commission to issue rules to protect the American people from energy outages expected to result from the loss of this fuel-secure generation capacity.”
The proposal does not specify what those expected outages are based on. Several organizations that monitor grid reliability and forecast resources have found that the nation’s electric grids have adequate resources to handle future demand even when taking into account the announced and predicted retirements of cash-strapped power plants.
Those assessments, including the one from the North American Electric Reliability Corp., a nonprofit that analyzes the grids in the U.S. and Canada, were referenced in the DOE’s grid study released last month.
The North American Electric Reliability Corp., in its long-term reliability assessment, did note that the increasing reliance on natural gas could raise problems for select areas where it pushes out most other sources.
The other issue with natural gas is that it serves at least two masters.
Most power plants aren’t likely to buy firm capacity on natural gas pipelines to ensure that a certain amount of supply gets to them. And most of the time, that’s not an issue; but in times of large demand, natural gas utilities that heat homes and power stoves get first dibs on gas.
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.