Donald Trump stood in front of the oil and gas industry in Pittsburgh in September and promised, “Oh, you will like me so much.”
“The permitting process in your industry is a disaster,” he said. “Every friend I have in your industry — they tell me it has become horrible with the EPA.”
And as for regulations, Mr. Trump felt the crowd’s pain.
“Probably no business has been more affected than your business when it comes to regulations,” he sympathized from the podium at the David L. Lawrence Convention Center last fall.
On Wednesday — the day after President Trump signed executive orders aiming to expedite two oil pipelines that were stymied under his predecessor, and to streamline pipeline permitting for others — the oil and gas industry gathered in the same space where Mr. Trump had made his promises and allowed itself the most muted, cautious optimism it could muster.
A cheerleader-in-chief won’t heal all of the industry’s wounds, they warned. In some cases, it may complicate things by galvanizing the opposition.
“We can all sit here and be very excited [that] we’ve got an administration that’s supportive of our business today,” said Alan Armstrong, president and CEO of The Williams Cos., an Oklahoma-based energy infrastructure firm.
“We can be very thankful about announcements like we saw yesterday,” he told the crowd at Hart’s Marcellus-Utica MIdstream Conference. “But I will tell you that is not changing the opposition that we have at a local level. And we’re going to continue to see that and, I will tell you, it may even enhance.”
For years, when Hart Energy has brought its oil and gas industry conferences to Pittsburgh, protesters have followed.
Inside the convention center hall, they are regarded as a nuisance but one that is causing some alarm in light of the large and high-profile protests that sprung up at the Standing Rock reservation to fight the Dakota Access pipeline.
In the latest edition of its Midstream Business magazine, Hart Energy had an editorial titled, “You Are The Target.”
“The extreme environmental movement has figured out the best way to break the oil and gas value chain … is to disrupt the link between the chain’s two ends,” Paul Hart, Hart’s editor-in-chief wrote.
Many in the industry say if you just tell the public the facts, you’ll get their support.
“No, you won’t,” he wrote. “We need to think like the emotional opposition if we want to defeat them.”
Outside the convention center, Lisa Kavanaugh stood at the corner of Penn Avenue and 10th Street on Wednesday, holding a sign explaining why new pipelines are “unnecessary,” “harmful” and “greed-driven.” She urged conference participants who walked by to think seven generations ahead before making any decisions.
Ms. Kavanaugh, who came from Oberlin, Ohio, stood with Spring Hill resident Phoenix Lagoon and his black Scottish terrier Princess Lucina while car horns honked in support.
The protest, which stationed about 20 people on all sides of two street corners, was organized by Kevin Mundy from Cleveland. Fresh off an unsuccessful run for Congress, Mr. Mundy said he was galvanized by the Nexus pipeline, a 255-mile pipe slated to run through four counties in his district and seeks to use eminent domain for parts of its route.
Inside the conference, Robert Huffman, director of business development of U.S. Transmission at Spectra Energy, which is developing the Nexus pipeline, said his company is “as optimistic as we’ve ever been about pipeline infrastructure” given the political environment. But none of its executives expect permitting to get easier, he said.
While company officials talked in cautious generalities about a friend in Washington, a group of lawyers attempted to break down what the past week of the Trump presidency has meant for this industry.
After his inauguration, Mr. Trump hit pause on all regulations in development and those recently finalized, which means that an ambitious overhaul in the way the federal government regulates the safety of natural gas and liquid pipelines is likely to be “headed in an entirely new direction,” said Keith Coyle, a shareholder at Babst Calland.
This week’s executive orders set a clear trend, said Kurt Krieger, principal at Steptoe & Johnson.
“The trend is build it, get ‘er done, don’t hold it up for environmental review,” he said.
At the same time, if environmental groups feel they aren’t getting their way with federal agencies, they are likely to step up their efforts, the lawyers said.
Scott Janoe, an environmental partner with Baker Botts LLP anticipates a swell of civil lawsuits that challenge companies directly on enforcement matters if they feel regulators aren’t doing it.
“We’ve seen a lot of saber-rattling from groups the day after the election” threatening these kinds of lawsuits, he said. “They’re gearing up.”
Anya Litvak: alitvak@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1455.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.