The web of pipelines that traverses Pennsylvania’s least populated stretches of farms and forests to tie shale gas wells to market would be subject to safety standards for the first time under a bill recently introduced in the Pennsylvania Senate.
The bill, sponsored by Sen. Lisa Baker, R-Luzerne, and backed by a bipartisan group of eastern Pennsylvania senators, would apply the kind of safety rules that control pipelines in more populated regions to rural lines that make up the vast majority of pipelines linking the state’s large and growing number of shale gas wells.
Senate Bill 1044 calls for the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission to regulate the rural lines with new rules for markings; incident reporting; corrosion control and maximum operating pressures; mapping; leak surveys; public notice and registration with the Pennsylvania One Call damage prevention system.
The PUC would also have authority to investigate the rural lines, issue fines and collect annual fees to pay for the regulatory program.
Federal construction, maintenance and inspection standards that are meant to ensure the safety of pipelines in relatively populated areas do not apply to gathering lines running through rural regions, where residents have pushed for expanded oversight for years.
Gathering lines are left unregulated in Class 1 areas — defined as having 10 or fewer buildings where people live or work within 220 yards of a mile-long stretch of pipeline — and Pennsylvania law currently bars the state PUC from adopting stricter standards than those in federal pipeline safety laws.
This is true even though the gathering lines carrying gas from Marcellus Shale and other unconventional well sites to major pipeline thoroughfares often have little resemblance to the narrow tubes that carried the low-pressure gas of past extraction eras. Now, the rural gathering lines can be just as large and subject to the same stress as transmission lines under state and federal watch.
The exempt gathering lines are also the most common. Through 2014, Pennsylvania pipeline operators have registered with the PUC 8,387 miles of natural gas gathering and transmission pipelines that draw half or more of their gas from shale wells and 83 percent of them are gathering lines in Class 1 areas.
The federal Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration is considering expanding some oversight but, since the federal agency has not acted, Pennsylvania should establish safety standards for rural lines, Ms. Baker said.
“What I’ve heard from some of my constituents who have Class 1 lines on their properties, they want safety as well,” she said. “They want assurances and the peace of mind that they are being constructed in the most safe manner.”
Ms. Baker said the minimum standards in the bill are the kinds of commonsense practices that many midstream operators have told her they are already following.
At least one industry trade group said the state rules are not necessary.
The Oklahoma-based Gas Processors Association, which represents midstream companies nationally, is concerned the bill “could not only negatively impact our members’ midstream operations in Pennsylvania, but could also affect jobs, taxes and local revenues in the state,” Debbie Beaver, the group’s state government affairs director, said.
Rural residents, who have watched waves of gathering lines being installed in their communities with varying degrees of conscientiousness, counter that a consistent standard is necessary.
“There are companies that I am aware of that do an excellent job,” said Emily Krafjack, a Wyoming County resident who advocates for fair treatment of communities in the Northern Tier shale gas fields. “But I don’t have the confidence that all companies are doing that.”
She said some companies have installed pipelines with methods or materials that would have required a special permit or would have been rejected entirely under federal laws that apply to lines in more populated areas.
The calculation of cost versus risk that has kept the Class 1 lines unregulated strikes her as cold math that leaves her neighbors unprotected.
“When you look at our rural communities, that sliding mile of 10 or less homes could be one extended family and their livelihood,” she said.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.