John Swart has no interest in having a bulky water line draped across his Washington County pasture and neither do his cows.

“They are very big lines,” the West Finley farmer and township supervisor said. “Animals crossing them — they could break a leg.”

So when a shale gas operator wanted to run a fluids pipeline through Mr. Swart’s property to get to a planned gas well, he agreed on the condition that the line be buried.

This year, that option seemed in doubt, until a single word — “and” — was added to a suite of proposed drilling regulatory changes last week that will allow shale gas companies to continue to bury wastewater pipelines that ferry fluids between a network of well sites and storage facilities.

Advertise with us

The economical edit by the state Department of Environmental Protection means that only temporary wastewater lines installed to serve one well site at a time will have to run above ground, where they can easily be monitored for leaks.

Only a few Marcellus Shale operators have installed buried wastewater lines, DEP officials said.

Buried pipelines that carry fresh water to well sites are far more common and the proposed regulations have always allowed those to run below ground.

Companies use the buried pipelines in areas of concentrated well development, where the lines will link many wells over long periods of time during fluid-intense stages like drilling and hydraulic fracturing. The lines are also installed where overland pipes or tanker traffic would be particularly disruptive. Or the pipelines are built to meet the standards of natural gas gathering lines so the same infrastructure can be used to carry gas away from the sites once wells are completed.

A push for the “and” started months ago, when the Marcellus Shale Coalition wrote in public comments that the way DEP defined “well development pipelines” in its revised oil and gas rules would prohibit the use of centralized semi-permanent underground pipelines.

Advertise with us

And that, the coalition said, would result in “hundreds of thousands of additional truck road hours per year to transport fluids.”

DEP made the edit only recently after Consol Energy and its joint venture partner Noble Energy, which have installed below-ground pipeline networks to transport fluids in their Marcellus Shale operating areas, met with regulators and helped community partners — including landowners, township officials, the Greene County Commissioners and the Pittsburgh Airport Area Chamber of Commerce — arrange a letter-writing campaign.

Mr. Swart sent in one of those letters.

“Reduced truck traffic, less risk of weather-related or accidental damage, less risk of vandalism, efficiencies that encourage water reuse and limit the need for disposal — all are benefits to maintaining this best practice,” Consol spokesman Brian Aiello said.

DEP’s new draft doesn’t explicitly allow or even address the buried, centralized lines. What’s clear is what they are not: well development pipelines, which DEP defines as those that transport fluids and wastes for drilling or fracking that also — this is where the “and” comes in — lose their usefulness after the well site has been reclaimed.

Advertise with us

DEP added an entirely new section to its rules to regulate those temporary lines after several failed, causing spills. Waste fluids from the Marcellus Shale contain significant amounts of salts, metals and other constituents that can be toxic in large doses.

“The original standard was the ‘it can’t leak’ standard,” Scott Perry, DEP’s deputy secretary for oil and gas management, told an advisory board in September. “That didn't work.”

New standards for temporary aboveground wastewater lines, like mandatory shut-off valves, regular inspections and pressure testing, won’t apply to buried centralized wastewater pipelines designed to service multiple sites or be converted to natural gas gathering lines after the wells start producing gas.

Instead, the longer-term wastewater lines will exist in a regulatory gray area that DEP, for now at least, is leaving undefined.

If a pipeline is not a well development pipeline or a gas gathering pipeline — both of which are defined in the proposed regulations — how would it be treated under the new rules? one advisory board member asked at a meeting last week.

Advertise with us

“It’s not regulated,” Mr. Perry said.

It may not stay that way for long. DEP wants to hear about the construction, testing and inspection standards that companies like Consol and Noble are already using to ensure the integrity of their buried lines.

Kurt Klapkowski, director of DEP’s bureau of oil and gas planning and program management, indicated at the September advisory board meeting, before the department made the recent edit, that simply putting wastewater lines above ground and in plain sight would preempt the need to develop more onerous regulations that buried lines would require.

“If we’re going to allow them to be buried in the future, we’re going to have to add corrosion control and leak detection requirements,” he said then. “Because if you’re going to be moving wastewater from a well site to a centralized impoundment in a buried pipe, you’ve got to know that it’s not leaking.”

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.