HARRISBURG — An advisory board to the Department of Environmental Protection put off any decision to endorse the final draft of a comprehensive and controversial revision to the state’s oil and gas well rules on Tuesday, with members saying they need to consider more feedback on the proposed changes that have been in the works for nearly five years.
The resolution to wait by the Oil and Gas Technical Advisory Board, whose five voting members are engineers, geologists or experienced drillers, will not affect the progress of the proposed rules, which will still be sent to the state’s Environmental Quality Board for a vote early next year on whether to adopt or modify the new requirements.
The regulations would separate rules for the unconventional industry extracting natural gas from the Marcellus and Utica shales and the conventional oil and gas industry. But the proposal has generated backlash from groups representing both the shale drillers and traditional drillers, who accuse the department of overreaching.
The oil and gas advisory board said it plans to present a report on the proposed rules to the environmental rule-making board after it has incorporated feedback from another DEP advisory committee that represents the interests of the state’s conventional drilling industry, which voted against the rules package this week.
Non-voting members on the advisory board — who are meant to represent the voices of community and environmental groups and other public interest constituencies and who were caught off-guard by the voting members’ resolution — asked that their feedback also be included in the advisory board’s eventual report.
The lack of an endorsement was a disappointment to the department, which has been working on the wide-ranging revisions under three governors and through two public review periods that garnered more than 30,000 comments, including many that favor stronger regulations.
“While not the ringing endorsement we had hoped for, we’re pleased nonetheless that it was certainly not a vote to disapprove the rules,” Scott Perry, DEP’s deputy secretary for oil and gas management, said.
The proposed rules include separate chapters for the unconventional industry and the conventional oil and gas industry, with its generally smaller operations and shallower wells. Major changes would strengthen standards for cleaning up spills, identifying underground hazards such as abandoned wells, operating large centralized wastewater storage ponds, and protecting public resources around well sites.
Trade groups for both the unconventional and conventional industry strongly oppose the rules, and DEP leaders have said they expect to face lawsuits once the rules are adopted.
The Conventional Oil and Gas Advisory Committee met to review the final draft on Thursday, and its members recommended that DEP not advance the regulations because they contend the rule-making process was fundamentally flawed. The committee does not have authority to hold up the regulations, but its protest will be forwarded to legislators and the state’s regulatory review agency.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.