By good luck and geology, the web of water infrastructure that treats and transfers drainage from Consol Energy’s coal mines in southwestern Pennsylvania runs through rich acreage used by companies drilling for gas in the Marcellus and Utica shales.

A gas producer, like Consol, in need of a plentiful water source to frack its wells can tap into one of the Cecil-based energy company’s existing lines and use treated mine water to displace some of the fresh water it would otherwise draw from rivers or public supplies.

A bill signed by Gov. Tom Wolf on Thursday will make it easier to turn wastewater from one type of fossil fuel extraction into a resource for another.

The bill, sponsored by Sen. Camera Bartolotta, R-Monongahela, clarifies liabilities for when oil and gas companies use coal companies’ treated mine water as an alternative to fresh water in hydraulic fracturing and other stages of oil and gas well development.

Advertise with us

The new law is narrowly tailored to deal with permitted mine discharges that meet standards set by environmental regulators, its sponsors said. It was not designed to address the persistent environmental scourge of drainage from the state’s many abandoned coal mines, which has left thousands of miles of Pennsylvania streams stained orange and nearly lifeless.

Instead, it defines the point when liability for treated water from active or closed mines is passed from the coal company to the oil and gas company that uses the mine water to develop its wells. It protects coal companies from responsibility for costs or damages associated with the offsite use of the water, and oil and gas companies from responsibility for treating the mine drainage before they get it.

Consol Energy, whose gas and coal operations have a natural synergy and shared acreage in the region, has for years been using treated mine water to develop its own wells and has sales agreements with other producers to allow them to use it in their wells, company officials said.

But the legal gray area muddying the handoff of liability had been an obstacle to wider adoption of the practice even in regions where mining and drilling happen close together.

The Pennsylvania Coal Alliance, an industry trade group, has not gathered data on how often coal companies are supplying treated mine water to oil and gas operators in the state. CEO John Pippy said it is likely “very limited.”

Advertise with us

“I definitely see, based on feedback from my companies, that there is interest in doing this going forward,” he said.

Representatives of several environmental groups were disappointed that Mr. Wolf signed the bill. The 22 groups had urged the governor to veto it in a letter that said the legislation gave “a far-reaching waiver of liability to coal and oil and gas companies in the Commonwealth — industrial sectors with a track record of pollution in Pennsylvania that we continue to try and remediate today, often at great expense.”

Other organizations that work to address harmful drainage from abandoned mines said the bill is a missed opportunity because it will not help them abate that persistent source of pollution.

“This bill does not stipulate ‘abandoned.’ This is for the active industry,” said Andy McAllister, regional coordinator for the Western Pennsylvania Coalition for Abandoned Mine Reclamation. “So, quite frankly, this is not an option to help our groups with anything that they are doing regarding the treatment of abandoned mine drainage, unfortunately.”

A spokeswoman for Ms. Bartolotta said it is important to continue having conversations about cleaning up and finding beneficial uses for abandoned mine drainage, but this bill was never meant to address that issue.

Advertise with us

“The senator wanted to be very targeted,” her chief of staff, Katrina Anderson, said.

She also disagreed with environmental groups’ characterization of the bill, which she said does not change or remove any of the existing environmental standards the industries have to meet.

“The use of treated mine water by natural gas companies is an innovative approach that will help preserve millions of gallons of fresh water,” Ms. Bartolotta said in a statement, “and I am thankful that more companies will have the freedom to explore this option.”

Even after questions about liability for treated mine water are resolved, operational hurdles — especially related to proximity and treatment needs — can still limit when mine water is a reasonable option for replacing fresh water for fracking, said David Yoxtheimer, an extension associate with Penn State’s Marcellus Center for Outreach and Research.

If the quality of the treated mine water suits the gas company’s needs, the permitted mine discharge point is close enough to pipe the water to wells, and the price is right, “That works,” he said. “But if it is some great distance away and it still needs more treatment, I think that’s where it starts to lose some of its luster.”

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.