Two oil and gas leasing cases that will be argued in front of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court next week have the potential to either modernize or seriously disrupt centuries-old state real estate laws that have roots in the days when tax collectors still rode horses and much of Penn’s Woods was wilderness.

Both of the cases feature old and complicated deeds, confusion about who owned oil and gas rights that had been severed from the surface property, and laws that aimed to sort out such disorder.

The first case, Shedden v. Anadarko, challenges a century-old legal principle in the state known as estoppel by deed, which gives a lessee — in this case, an oil and gas company — the benefit of the original agreement if a property owner signs a contract to lease what he owns, finds out he doesn't own all of it and later acquires it.

The Superior Court cited the “well-settled” estoppel by deed doctrine when it sided with Anadarko E&P Co. in its decision last year. But the three-judge panel noted the doctrine had never been applied in Pennsylvania appeals court decisions involving oil and gas leases, although other states’ courts have used it in oil and gas disputes.

Advertise with us

At stake in the Supreme Court’s review is the legitimacy of legal precedents and common lease terms that help ensure oil and gas companies get access to all of the property that landowners intend to lease, whether or not convoluted title issues are discovered later, as often happens in a state where early deeds were handwritten in cursive.

In the second case, Herder Spring Hunting Club v. Keller, the court will look at a long-retired practice called title washing. In that practice, undeveloped surface property is reunited with its severed mineral rights during a tax sale if the mineral rights had not been registered with county officials and separately assessed for taxes.

Looking for a log cabin

Property registration for unimproved land was required under an 1806 law. Otherwise, attorney Michael Vennum of Burleson LLP explained, “When the tax collector is riding his horse down the road, if he can’t tell that your property is developed because there is no log cabin on it, the tax collector won’t naturally know that he is supposed to tax that land.”

If mineral owners had failed to register their property and the surface property was later seized for unpaid taxes, the separate title for the minerals would be “washed away” at the tax sale and the new owner would get both the surface and the minerals.

Advertise with us

The Superior Court upheld title washing last year, even though the three-judge panel said it “may be seen as being unduly harsh,” because it was the appropriate practice at the time that the property at issue in the case was seized and sent to tax sale in 1935.

Undoing past title washes now could force the reevaluation of oil and gas ownership for substantial amounts of property, especially in the state’s northern regions.

The state Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, for example, said in a friend of the court brief in May that an unknown but “significant” amount of Pennsylvania’s 2.2 million acres of state forest may have mineral rights that had been “washed” in long-ago tax sales.

“A reversal of the Superior Court’s well reasoned determination in this case could subject DCNR to adverse claims in the billions of dollars,” the agency’s lawyers wrote. “In addition, the loss of public lands would be unprecedented and devastating to the state forest system and the public as a whole.”

Attorneys tend to think the Supreme Court took up the cases as an opportunity to put a modern stamp on ancient laws and precedents, not to overrule them.

Advertise with us

“Lawyers like myself are looking for modern appellate court decisions to guide us on these issues,” Mr. Vennum said.

The most sweeping alternative, that the Supreme Court tosses out the established principles, is hard to imagine, he said.

“If the Supreme Court comes back and says now title washing is unconstitutional or it violates due process — oh my goodness. Who owns the oil and gas now?”

The court is scheduled to hear arguments in both cases in Pittsburgh on Oct. 7.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com