A state oil and gas trade group set up a legal bout with environmental regulators over requirements for well drilling permit applications in two venues at once this spring — the state Supreme Court and the Commonwealth Court.

It was knocked out of one but it is still fighting in the other.

On Aug. 20, the Supreme Court denied the Pennsylvania Independent Oil and Gas Association’s application to intervene in an ongoing case over issues left to be sorted out in Act 13, the state’s 2012 revision of its oil and gas law to deal with shale development, after the high court threw out significant parts of the act in late 2013.

PIOGA argues the Department of Environmental Protection continues to rely on one of the prohibited parts of Act 13 when it requires companies to consider the impact of their proposed wells on public resources as part of their drilling permit applications.

Advertise with us

In particular, two DEP forms and policies require companies applying to drill a well near features like state parks and protected species to coordinate with the agencies that manage those resources and prepare detailed plans to protect them.

PIOGA sought to intervene in the Supreme Court case so that it could petition the court to force DEP to comply with the earlier judgment and stop the agency from requiring companies to perform the public resource reviews.

Despite the setback in the high court, the Wexford-based trade group is continuing its parallel challenge in Commonwealth Court, where a judge has tentatively scheduled arguments on preliminary objections in the case for November.

“We believe it is important that DEP abide by the law,” PIOGA general counsel Kevin Moody said. “While it is important that a court require DEP to abide by the law, it is not overly important which court orders DEP to do so.”

A DEP spokesman declined to comment on the cases, except to say the department was pleased with the Supreme Court’s ruling.

Advertise with us

In court filings, the department has focused largely on procedural issues — especially that PIOGA has not established its standing in the case and that it has picked the wrong venues for its challenges. PIOGA should first appeal a particular permit decision to the state’s Environmental Hearing Board if it wants to challenge the DEP’s public resource protection procedures, DEP said.

But it is also clear the department and PIOGA read the Supreme Court’s decision differently. PIOGA’s court filings say that the public resource protection sections of Act 13 were invalidated. DEP attorneys, on the other hand, note that key sections were only invalidated “to the extent that” they implement or enforce other sections of the law that the court rejected — a reading that would allow DEP to continue to apply the reviews.

DEP looked for clarity on this issue in 2014 when it asked the Supreme Court to send the case back to the Commonwealth Court for further review as part of a broader request for reconsideration, but the high court denied it.

PIOGA’s challenge exasperates environmental legal advocates, who argued against allowing the trade group to intervene in the Supreme Court case.

“We’re talking about state parks,” said attorney Jordan Yeager, who represents municipalities and environmental groups in the ongoing Act 13 case. “They don’t want DEP to consider what the impacts will be on state parks? It’s really not what a responsible industry would be doing.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Yeager said even if DEP did not rely on the disputed section of Act 13 to require companies to protect public natural resources, the environmental rights amendment to the state constitution gives DEP that mandate.

PIOGA argues that if the courts rule in its favor it “will not leave the Commonwealth’s public resources unprotected” because other federal and state laws protect public spaces and threatened species.

The court’s decision in the case will influence pending state oil and gas rules that are scheduled for final approval next spring and that are expected to spur more lawsuits.

One section of the proposed rules expands the kinds of public resources that require special consideration to playgrounds and common areas of schools. It also lays out how DEP will determine whether to put special conditions on drilling near those sites.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com.