Harrisburg is feeling the natural gas industry’s financial blues.
Stubbornly low natural gas prices that have companies cutting jobs and cropping drilling budgets are influencing policy debates over energy issues at the Capitol, like whether to enact a severance tax and how best to expand pipelines to get the glut of gas to customers.
For Pennsylvania’s natural gas industry, there has never been a good time for the state to tax the gas that companies draw from the resource-rich Marcellus and Utica shales, but now, they say, would be the worst.
Legislators in the Republican-controlled General Assembly have heard, and sometimes echoed, that message as Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf pushes to enact the severance tax he promised to deliver during his campaign.
The sector’s current slump has given the industry and its most stalwart supporters in the Legislature new resolve to defeat the extraction tax proposed by Mr. Wolf, as well as nearly a dozen severance tax measures introduced this session by lawmakers from both parties.
“I’ve seen people who didn’t want a shale tax to begin with being more resolute that the price is so low that we just can’t do it to them,” said Rep. Kate Harper, a Republican from Montgomery County, who introduced a severance tax bill in January.
Her bill would maintain the current impact fee that gas companies pay for each well they drill and add a new 3.5 percent tax on the value of gas produced — “to tax the shale a bit” she said, “but still not drive them out of the state.”
“They can afford a little more,” she said, then added. “Maybe not this year.”
“The timing may be off. I admit that. But I do think most Pennsylvanians think we probably should tax the shale more than we’re taxing them.”
Political observers note that the stalemate over a severance tax has to be viewed within the context of the state’s broader budget showdown and its politically divided government. The downturn in the natural gas market is one factor making opposite sides of the debate more entrenched in their positions.
“As a general rule, it probably has made the industry and the governor more at odds with each other,” said G. Terry Madonna, the director of Franklin & Marshall College’s Center for Politics and Public Affairs.
“At the moment, there’s no give,” he said.
Elected officials from the state’s core drilling regions argue that low natural gas prices should motivate the state to do more to take advantage of the gas buried here, by promoting natural gas as a vehicle fuel, expanding natural gas service to residents and businesses, and encouraging manufacturers that rely on a steady gas supply to build here.
“In state policy, we’re emphasizing the wrong thing,” said Sen. Gene Yaw, R-Lycoming, whose district encompasses an area of northeastern Pennsylvania that produces a significant amount of the state’s shale gas. “We’re trying to tax it, and I think that’s exactly the wrong way to go. What we should be doing is we should have programs to encourage its development and use.”
Mr. Yaw said he is disappointed by a lack of support for efforts to help build a market for the gas within the state’s borders.
“Other people, they don’t have the same passion for it. And it’s frustrating to me,” he said.
One area of significant focus for policymakers is pipeline development, which is understood to be crucial for moving more gas to market and eventually allowing prices to rebound enough to spur more drilling.
Mr. Wolf announced last week the 48 members of a new pipeline taskforce, which will recommend policies and best practices for planning and placing pipelines in a way that minimizes environmental and community impacts, improves public participation and makes permitting more efficient.
A wave of pipeline development was coming anyway, said Diana Stares, the director of the Center for Energy Policy and Management at Washington & Jefferson College. “But even the current administration is embracing whatever needs to be done in order to facilitate that,” she said.
Energy policy analysts also see the downturn giving state leaders and residents a more mature understanding of how the natural gas industry cycles through slumps and booms. That lesson can be valuable for developing long-term policies that take advantage of the industry without developing a lopsided reliance on it.
“It is conceivable that the slump in the market will give the commonwealth that breathing room to really sit down and assess, what is the best way to live with this industry, to support it and benefit from it as well,” Ms. Stares said.
“We’ve had a hard time stepping back because we really haven’t had that breathing room,” she said.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.