Pennsylvania is on track this year to bring in the smallest amount of impact fee revenue from shale gas wells since the fee was adopted in 2012, according to new projections published by the state’s Independent Fiscal Office.

Low natural gas prices, fewer new wells and declining production in older wells will likely combine to shrink the total 2015 impact fee payments between $14.9 million and $33.9 million from last year, the IFO said. Pennsylvania received $223.5 million in impact fee revenues for 2014.

If drilling and production trends for the first half of the year continue, Pennsylvania will collect $189.6 million for 2015, the IFO said. If drilling picks up moderately through the end of the year and older wells continue to produce enough gas to qualify for the fee, the state can expect to collect $196.1 million.

In the most optimistic of the three scenarios, the state will collect $208.6 million in impact fees for 2015. But that scenario assumes that the number of new horizontal wells drilled this year will be the same as last year — an improbable outcome since new well starts are down roughly 30 percent so far this year. It also assumes that no more older wells this year will see production declines that make them ineligible for the fee.

Advertise with us

That best-case scenario, the fiscal office said, “demonstrates that even under very optimistic assumptions, [calendar year] 2015 impact fee revenues will decline substantially” if low natural gas prices persist throughout 2015, as analysts expect.

Pennsylvania has never raised less than $200 million a year since it began collecting impact fees in 2012. It raised the least amount of annual impact fee revenue so far — $202.5 million — in 2012.

Companies drilling for gas in the Marcellus Shale and other hard-to-crack rock formations pay the highest impact fee when they drill a new well and pay lower amounts in subsequent years for up to 15 years. The fee is based on the annual average price of gas on the New York Mercantile Exchange, which is projected to fall below $3 per million British thermal units this year. If the lower price holds, as the fiscal office assumes it will, companies will have to pay $5,000 less per well this year than last year under the terms of the law.

Impact fees are assessed after each calendar year and the payments are due to the state every April.

Chances are slim that drilling will pick up enough in the second half of the year to make up for the declines in the first half, the IFO said. Gas production reports collected by the state show companies already have “significant unused production capacity” in the form of nearly 1,000 wells that have been drilled but not yet completed to produce gas and an additional 760 wells that are capable of production but have been turned off.

Advertise with us

“This large inventory of non‐producing wells, as well as low spot prices, suggest that new drilling activity will not offset reductions from the first half of the year,” the IFO said.

Much of the impact fee revenue is sent to communities that host shale gas wells to compensate them for the impacts on roads, services and landscapes that come with the development of wells. Impact fees are also allocated to state environmental, infrastructure, emergency management and housing programs.

Distributions to state agencies — about $18 million — are fixed each year and come first, Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission spokesman Nils Hagen-Frederiksen said. Sixty percent of the remaining balance gets distributed to counties and municipalities with wells, and 40 percent goes into a fund that is used for water, sewer and highway projects and county environmental initiatives.

The funding hierarchy means communities will likely share a smaller pot of money if the IFO’s projections are realized, but the exact breakdown is hard to predict.

“With so many variables potentially affecting the calculations, it’s extremely difficult to forecast any impact (positive or negative) on individual municipalities,” Mr. Hagen-Frederiksen said.

Advertise with us

The new impact fee projections come as Democratic Gov. Tom Wolf and the Republican-controlled General Assembly try again to reach a consensus on a state budget. One of Mr. Wolf’s budget priorities is to raise money for education, energy development and environmental protection with a new severance tax on shale gas production, which the Legislature’s Republican leaders oppose. They say the current impact fee is a tax that strikes a fair balance for gas producers and the state.

Mr. Wolf’s spokesman Jeffrey Sheridan said the lower impact fee projections bolster the case for the governor’s severance tax proposal, which would maintain the impact fee’s distribution to state programs and communities and raise more money for education.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com