The state Department of Environmental Protection would have to scrap its effort to update rules for Pennsylvania’s traditional oil and gas drilling industry and begin the 4-year-old rulemaking process again under the terms of an amendment that House Republicans added to a key state budget bill late Sunday.
Following a similar maneuver by the Legislature last year, environmental regulators have already split the state’s current and proposed drilling rules into two chapters — one for the technologically advanced unconventional drilling industry that targets the Marcellus and other deep shale formations and another for the conventional industry that generally operates shallow, vertical wells, some of which are a century old.
The amendment added to the budget-related Fiscal Code bill Sunday night prohibits the DEP from finalizing any conventional well site rules that are under consideration and revokes the department’s package of proposed conventional drilling rules, which has gone through two rounds of public comment since it was published in December 2013.
Steve Miskin, a spokesman for the House Republican majority, said the amendment is necessary because the DEP’s divided rules do not fully comply with the Legislature’s directive for the two industries to be regulated differently.
“This is basically telling DEP, ‘Stop. They are dramatically different types of wells and you need to have separate regs,’” he said.
Gov. Tom Wolf, a Democrat, has said he will veto all or part of the Republican-crafted budget proposal that is working its way through the Legislature. The Fiscal Code, a crucial companion to the budget bill, has been used at times to advance provisions that have little to do with designating how taxpayer funds are spent.
DEP Secretary John Quigley resolved Monday that the agency will modernize rules for the conventional industry, whether it does so through the current rules package slated to take effect next spring or with a fresh start.
If the Fiscal Code amendment survives the budget process it might delay the implementation of revised rules for the traditional drilling industry but “it is not going to stop it,” Mr. Quigley said.
“Based on the data and our experience with the industry, the regulations need to be updated to protect public health and the environment and we will go forward within the confines of whatever laws are passed to make sure that that happens,” Mr. Quigley said.
Conventional drilling trade groups detest DEP’s proposed rules, which they say will cripple the industry, and they have used many strategies, from lobbying to lawsuits, to try to stop the revisions.
Arthur Stewart, secretary of the Pennsylvania Grade Crude Oil Coalition, said the amendment is a matter of survival for the state’s conventional industry and it is meant to clarify what the Legislature intended all along when it directed DEP to separate the rules last year.
“The Legislature had in mind that the unconventional regulations would continue forward and conventional would start over,” he said.
Environmental advocates were outraged by the late-night addition to the Fiscal Code bill of a proposal that has not been available for scrutiny.
“This is something that, if the Legislature tried to hold a vote on it, wouldn't pass. So the only route is to go in this very secretive, backdoor manner,” said Matt Stepp, policy director for the environmental group PennFuture.
David Hess, a DEP secretary under former Republican Governors Tom Ridge and Mark Schweiker, said the practice of tucking legislation into the must-pass Fiscal Code bill is “very undemocratic.”
“It avoids committees, it avoids public hearings, it avoids the House or the Senate or both voting on individual legislation,” he said.
Worse, he said, is the fact that the Fiscal Code amendment regarding drilling regulations was never introduced or debated as a stand-alone bill.
“This is the first time this language has surfaced anywhere,” he said. “I just think it is an abomination.”
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.