Sponsors of a Pennsylvania bill that would prohibit natural gas producers from paying landowners a smaller royalty fraction than the minimum share required by a 1979 law are hoping that this time simple will mean success.

During the last legislative session, a more wide-ranging royalty owner protection proposal collapsed. But Rep. Garth Everett, a Lycoming County Republican, believes the bill he introduced last week with 38 co-sponsors from both parties, will have a better second act — if his party’s leaders give it a chance.

“I removed some of the things that they found very difficult to live with,” Mr. Everett said. “Hopefully this time I will be able to get enough support in my caucus to go to our leadership and say, ’I know you might not love this bill but I think we should have an opportunity to run it.’”

House Bill 1391 establishes that the one-eighth — or 12.5 percent — minimum royalty defined by the 1979 Guaranteed Minimum Royalty Act is the true floor for what landowners can be paid for their share of natural gas extracted from their property.

Advertise with us

Companies frequently deduct from royalty checks expenses for things like compression, transportation and marketing that add up after gas is produced from a well head. Many leases require landowners with a royalty stake in the well to share those post-production costs, while other leases are silent on the matter or forbid it.

The issue inflames leaseholders who have seen royalty checks already diminished by low commodity prices shrink even further with the deductions for post-production costs. Lawsuits have been filed to fight deductions that royalty owners claim violate their lease terms or amount to fraud.

Pennsylvania Attorney General Kathleen Kane said this spring that her office is close to finishing an investigation into complaints that gas companies have cheated landowners of royalties, although she gave no hint of the result.

The state Department of Conservation and Natural Resources, which has hundreds of thousands of acres under lease for oil and gas development, is pursuing two forms of audits — on gas volume and price — to ensure the DCNR is being paid all that it is owed for the gas being pulled from beneath state forests and waterways.

“None of our leases allow post-production deductions,” said DCNR spokeswoman Christina Novak. “There have been times when companies have had different interpretations.”

Advertise with us

The deductions that lawmakers aim to correct with House Bill 1391 are those that take the royalty below the one-eighth minimum.

“It’s very simple: an eighth is an eighth is an eighth,” Mr. Everett said. “That’s what the statute has said since 1979. That was its intent.”

The Marcellus Shale Coalition said in a statement that it is still reviewing the bill, but it cast the issue as a fairly isolated one.

“It’s important to recognize that post production-related issues — which have been extremely localized and not widespread — are being actively addressed in the courts where contract matters should be addressed,” the North Fayette-based trade group said.

Advocates for royalty owners said it is a myth that deductions for gas transportation and processing are primarily associated with one company or with the northeast Pennsylvania region.

Advertise with us

“Some of the most egregious examples of deductions are from leases and royalty statements here in Western Pennsylvania,” said Robert Burnett, an oil and gas attorney at Downtown-based Houston Harbaugh, who called the practice widespread.

Jackie Root, president of the Pennsylvania chapter of the National Association of Royalty Owners, said not all but “almost all” of the exploration and production companies active in the Marcellus are taking deductions from 12.5 percent royalties.

“We have a very contentious issue here that is really robbing thousands of royalty owners of what’s due them,” she said.

Industry representatives have urged her group to focus on beating back a proposed severance tax on natural gas production, a tax the royalty owners group does not support. But Ms. Root said the royalty deduction issue is the group’s top priority and should be settled first.

“I know one individual that has over $1 million in deductions that are improper,” she said. “We shouldn't be grateful for a large amount of money if it’s half the large amount of money we should have had.”

Advertise with us

Rep. John Maher, R-Upper St. Clair, expressed support for the bill, which is also backed by the Pennsylvania Farm Bureau and the Pennsylvania State Grange. Mr. Maher leads the House Environmental Resources and Energy committee, which will likely be the bill’s first stop on its way to the floor.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com