HARRISBURG — Pennsylvania can do more to hire track inspectors and to push for stricter tank safety standards to address the growing number of trains carrying crude oil from Midwestern shale fields through Pennsylvania, state senators were told during a hearing on Tuesday.
Tankers filled with crude oil travel on 700 miles of the nearly 5,600 miles of total rail lines in the state, shipping hundreds of thousands of barrels of the fossil fuel to East Coast refineries near Philadelphia and elsewhere. While Pennsylvania has not seen the explosive derailments that have happened in neighboring states and Canada, close calls have brought greater scrutiny to the way the oil is shipped.
The state Senate’s transportation and energy committees held the joint hearing to discuss what is being done, and what might be done differently, to ensure the volatile cargo’s safe travel through communities.
Representatives of the two railroads carrying crude oil through the state — Norfolk Southern and CSX — emphasized that 99.9 percent of those loads get to their destination without incident, and that the companies invest in extensive inspection technology, infrastructure and equipment to try to prevent derailments.
They asked for help advocating for stricter federal tank standards, including requiring thermal tank covers that could survive as long as 800 minutes — rather than 100 minutes — in a pool of fire without rupturing. The federal Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration has not adopted those standards even as the agency updates other tank safety requirements.
“We’re baffled by the fact that the cars are not being required to have a higher safety standard,” said Rudy Husband, the resident vice president of government relations for Norfolk Southern.
Rail safety is largely regulated by the federal government, but rail safety inspectors and engineers with the Pennsylvania Public Utility Commission “play a very important but supportive role,” PUC chairwoman Gladys Brown said.
The PUC’s rail safety division has seen significant turnover and has had difficulty attracting qualified candidates, in part because Pennsylvania’s average salary for the positions — $41,100 in 2012 — was the lowest among all states except West Virginia and $15,500 less than the national average at the time, Ms. Brown said.
Pennsylvania also has fewer inspectors for every mile of track than neighboring states, she said.
“Even though right now we have a full complement, we know that we need to increase our level in terms of the number of inspectors,” she said.
Local and state emergency management officials testified that there should be more crude-by-rail specific training opportunities in Pennsylvania for first responders to prepare for what they called the “key emergency window” of several hours between a derailment and the time rail industry crews are likely to arrive on scene with specialized resources.
“We feel that this is a low probability threat,” Lancaster County Commissioner Scott Martin said. “However, if it occurs [it] would be a very dangerous and tedious incident.”
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.