The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency announced in late May, long past its deadline, how much biofuel should be blended into the nation’s supply of gasoline and diesel this year and next. But it is too soon to tell whether the proposal will settle the uncertainty that the delay caused in the renewable fuels market.

The Renewable Fuel Standard, which was created and expanded by laws in 2005 and 2007, sets annual volumes for how much traditional corn-based ethanol and advanced fuels made from things like plant waste and recycled cooking oil have to be mixed in with the fossil fuels used for transportation.

With its new targets, EPA said that the law was too aggressive: both the consumption of gasoline and the development of cellulosic ethanol — lower carbon-emitting fuel made from inedible plants like wood and grass — have been slower than Congress expected when it set the mandates in 2007. Many vehicle and other engines are not designed to run on fuel blends with higher than 10 percent ethanol, so mandating more biofuels could spur more production than the transportation system is ready to absorb.

EPA set the long-overdue 2014 renewable fuel volumes at the levels that were actually used last year, and set growing targets for all renewable fuels through 2016 and for biomass-based diesel through 2017.

Advertise with us

Those targets represent “ambitious responsible growth” in the biofuels market, Janet McCabe, the acting assistant administrator for EPA’s Office of Air, said. EPA is proposing to require refiners to use 16.3 billion gallons of renewable fuel this year and 17.4 billions gallons next year. But the proposed quotas are lower than the levels established in the law, which called for using 20.5 billion gallons of biofuel this year and 22.25 billion gallons next year.

“We’re balancing two dynamics: Congress’s clear intent to increase renewable fuels over time to address climate change and increase energy security and the real-world circumstances that have slowed progress to these goals,” Ms. McCabe said in a conference call with reporters.

None of the industries waiting for the announcement were satisfied with that attempt at balance, and the proposal is likely to end up in court after the EPA finalizes the targets in November.

“No one’s happy with what EPA did,” said Kevin Sunday, government affairs manager with the Pennsylvania Chamber of Business and Industry, which thinks the renewable fuel standards should be scrapped. “The ethanol lobby is mad that more biofuel isn't being mandated. The refineries aren’t happy because [the standards] are a year-and-a-half late and it still costs an awful lot of money. Some of the fuel stations are at a loss as to what they are going to be expected to do because some of their equipment isn’t necessarily designed” for a fuel mix with a higher percentage of ethanol.

U.S. Sen. Pat Toomey, R-Pa., introduced legislation this year with Sen. Dianne Feinstein, D-Calif., to repeal the corn ethanol mandate in the Renewable Fuel Standard. Mr. Toomey pointed in particular to the costs that Philadelphia-area refineries have to bear from purchasing renewable fuel credits under the program.

Advertise with us

“I will continue to fight to get rid of the renewable fuel standard altogether,” he said in a statement. “This requirement drives up the price of corn and many food products, making it harder for families to put a meal on their table. It also drives up gas prices, damages car engines, and is harmful to the environment.”

EPA admitted that its delay in setting the standards “led to uncertainty in the marketplace,” Ms. McCabe said, but she said the targets proposed on May 29 will “help provide the certainty that the marketplace needs to allow these low-carbon fuels to further develop.”

The targets come too late to help some biofuel producers. Keystone Biofuels, a Cumberland County biodiesel plant, filed to reorganize under a Chapter 11 bankruptcy in 2013, but an early version of EPA’s proposed 2014 biofuel targets and delays in finalizing the rule scared off potential investment partners, the company’s founder, Ben Wootton, wrote to EPA Administrator Gina McCarthy in January.

“My business was liquidated and I lost everything,” he wrote.

A proposed Monaca biodiesel plant also cited uncertainty caused by the EPA’s indecision as one factor that put plans for the plant on hold late last year.

Advertise with us

“If you’re a bank and you want to finance a company that wants to build a refinery, for example, why would you want to invest your money into a regulatory environment that was that uncertain and that subject to change?” said Lara Fowler, a research fellow at Penn State’s Institutes of Energy and the Environment.

Whether the announced volumes will restore some certainty to the marketplace and increase investors’ confidence in the biofuels sector is unclear, she said. The rule still has to go through a public comment period before the final targets are set in November.

“I think people will be watching for what commentary comes out, and then what EPA does in November of this year, and then who sues them,” she said.

Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com