Pennsylvania environmental regulators say they got more public feedback early last year on their proposal to update rules for oil and gas operations than on most rules on any topic the Department of Environmental Protection had proposed in the past.
Regulators then had the difficult task of synthesizing the comments, which at the extremes, either encouraged the agency to scrap the rules and start over or to make the regulations stricter.
More than a year later, with a revised draft and a new governor in charge, DEP is facing the same challenge as it begins to review hundreds of new comments on its proposed final version of the regulations, which will touch everything from noise control to waste handling at oil and gas well sites.
The agency also is facing a new hurdle this round.
Many industry groups, individual companies and their supporters in the legislature argue that DEP skirted the proper process for developing new rules, misconstrued legislative directives and invented the authority to implement some of the significant changes they have planned.
Leaders in DEP’s oil and gas division have said their authority and the process are both legally sound, but they expect to be challenged in court.
Between its first and final drafts, DEP added an entirely new section for noise mitigation at well sites, moved to phase out large wastewater holding lagoons that have been susceptible to leaks, and added schools and playgrounds to the list of public resources that should be given extra consideration when wells are planned nearby, among other things.
The foundational criticism submitted by the industry and its allies is that DEP made such substantial changes between drafts that those sections should be pulled from the package and go through a separate rulemaking process, so that legislative oversight committees and the state’s Independent Regulatory Review Commission can weigh the revised proposal’s costs, benefits and need.
“By inserting complex new provisions that were not previously discussed into the final draft rulemaking, thereby waiting until the proverbial ‘11th hour’ of the process, the DEP is impeding the role of the appropriate legislative oversight committees and Independent Regulatory Review Commission to adequately comment and if necessary object to the substantive aspects of these regulations,” the leaders of the state House of Representatives’ Gas and Oil Caucus wrote.
The conventional oil and gas industry, which generally operates shallower, lower-pressure wells than the producers pulling gas from the Marcellus Shale, say DEP also should start again with its revised rules for conventional wells to comply with the legislature’s directive to create separate regulations for the different drilling industries.
“In many ways, our members have more in common with Pennsylvania’s Amish population than they do with large, billion-dollar unconventional well operators whose proliferation across Pennsylvania is the driving force behind the department’s regulatory effort,” wrote the Bradford-based Pennsylvania Independent Petroleum Producers Association, which represents small conventional producers in northwestern Pennsylvania who predominantly tend existing wells with methods that haven’t changed much in decades.
Oil and gas companies and trade groups predict a dire result if the proposed rules are allowed to go forward as drafted.
The Pennsylvania Independent Oil and Gas Association in Wexford said the new and expanded provisions in the final draft “will significantly burden” both the conventional and unconventional oil and gas industry in Pennsylvania “to the point of stagnation.”
“These draft final regulations introduce a level of burden, ambiguity and arbitrariness that will make it extremely difficult for our members to continue to commit capital to operations in Pennsylvania faced with such potential costs and uncertainty,” the North Fayette-based Marcellus Shale Coalition wrote.
Range Resources, the Fort Worth, Texas-based oil and gas company with significant operations in southwestern Pennsylvania, wrote that the draft final regulations appear to be “an intentional attempt to stifle” the industry. The proposed rules “introduce such a combination of over-regulation coupled with vague and ambiguous terms and requirements” that it will “make continuing investment in Pennsylvania problematic.”
The Warren-based Pennsylvania Grade Crude Oil Coalition, which represents conventional operators that drill new wells, wrote that the costs to comply with the proposed rules would be greater than the entire gross revenue from all annual sales of oil and gas from the state’s conventional industry.
Not all oil and gas companies responded to the department’s proposals with doomsaying. Most offered targeted suggestions for improvement and, in some cases, gave their qualified support to DEP’s ideas.
Royal Dutch Shell’s regional exploration and production subsidiary, for example, commended DEP for working with an array of stakeholders throughout the rulemaking process and supported DEP’s proposal to eliminate centralized impoundments for storing vast amounts of wastewater for reuse — a practice other companies argued to keep.
Environmental, community and public health groups embraced many of DEP’s proposed changes and urged the agency to provide further protection. Chief among the recommendations was to require at least a one-mile buffer between schools and oil and gas operations. Many also encouraged DEP to prohibit open pits of any kind for storing and disposing of oilfield waste and to ban companies from burying solid waste from the drilling process on well sites.
Several environmental groups pushed DEP to do more to protect public resources, such as public parks, schools and habitats for rare species. The current proposal allows DEP to add protective conditions to drilling permits near those resources, but regulators have to prove the conditions are necessary if the oil and gas company appeals.
The environmental legal organization Earthjustice, writing on behalf of more than a dozen other environmental groups, said operators, not DEP, should bear the burden of proof, while the Philadelphia-based Clean Air Council argued DEP should be required, not simply allowed, to impose protective permit conditions when it finds that a well will likely harm public resources.
“The rule as written allows for an absurd result: the DEP finds that there is a probable harmful impact on a public resource but does nothing about it,” the Clean Air Council wrote.
Environmental groups also urged the department to finish the rules swiftly and implement them without unnecessary delays.
The proposed rules have to be finalized by early 2016 in order to keep to a timeline mandated by state law. DEP has promised to meet the deadline. If it doesn’t, the regulation package would be considered withdrawn and the review process would have to start again.
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.