HARRISBURG — Gov. Tom Wolf’s proposed severance tax on shale gas would shift Pennsylvania from having the lowest to the highest effective severance tax rate among seven major gas-producing states, but most of the tax likely would be paid by out-of-state consumers, the head of Pennsylvania’s Independent Fiscal Office testified on Monday.
Matthew Knittel, director of the non-partisan office that provides budget analysis, gave the new assessment of the tax during a joint hearing of the state Senate’s energy and finance committees.
The fiscal office’s analysis expects producers eventually will pass the cost of the tax on to end users, roughly 80 percent of which will be outside of Pennsylvania in coming years.
The combined terms of Mr. Wolf’s proposed tax on both the value and volume of Marcellus Shale natural gas are projected to amount to a 17.3 percent tax in 2016, the first year it would take effect, Mr. Knittel said. Beyond the end of the decade, as prices rise and pipelines are built to take more gas to consumers out of state, the average tax rate should approach 7.3 percent, he said.
The impact fee that shale gas producers currently pay on the number of wells they drill will amount to a 4.7 percent tax on the market value of annual production in 2015 due to very low natural gas prices at Pennsylvania trading points, he said. The fee has in past years ranged between an effective tax rate of 2 percent and 4 percent.
Mr. Wolf, a Democrat, is proposing a 5 percent tax on the value of gas and natural gas liquids from shale wells, plus 4.7 cents per thousand cubic feet of gas extracted. A key piece of his budget package, Mr. Wolf’s tax proposal sets a $2.97 per thousand cubic feet minimum value for shale gas, regardless of the actual sale price, which has been considerably lower recently.
Acting Department of Revenue Secretary Eileen McNulty, who opened the hearing by describing the benefits of Mr. Wolf’s tax proposal for funding education, environmental oversight and other programs, testified that the administration is closely monitoring the natural gas market, and Mr. Wolf is open to reassessing the controversial floor price if necessary.
Ms. McNulty said the tax will raise $2 billion for basic education over the next four years.
She faced tough questions from Republican senators on the committees who did not hide their support for the state’s oil and gas industries or their skepticism of the proposed tax.
“I actually thought about wearing a T-shirt today saying, ‘I love fossil fuels,’ because I do,” Sen. Scott Hutchinson, R-Venango, quipped.
Several oil and gas industry trade groups testified that a severance tax would harm both their member companies and the broader state economy.
“The dialogue on this important issue has become centered around a fundamentally false choice: you’re either for a higher energy tax or you’re against children’s education and future,” said David Spigelmyer, president of the North Fayette-based Marcellus Shale Coalition. “By exploiting children to suggest that the natural gas industry is to blame for the failings of our state’s longstanding structural fiscal challenges is absurd.”
Several Democratic senators suggested that publicly traded oil and gas producers have been telling a much brighter story to their investors during recent earnings reports than the dire predictions offered to the committee.
Sen. John Blake, D-Lackawanna, said, “The manner in which the industry hedges itself against risk and the way it has been communicating to its stockholders evidences, I think, a bullish attitude on the part of this industry in terms of future prospects.”
Laura Legere: llegere@post-gazette.com



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.