After listening to more than two hours of testimony, questions and concerns from residents, the Cecil Zoning Hearing Board Monday voted to delay action on a longstanding, controversial request for a Marcellus Shale natural gas compressor station. The move came after MarkWest Liberty Midstream & Resources offered to give the board another month to consider options.
With their legal options exhausted, board members said they had no choice but to approve the request by the company to build a compressor station along Route 980 near the intersection with Route 50.
“We must grant this,” said board Chairman George Augustine. “The case has already been decided. It’s over.”
The board was taking final public comments before voting to approve the application Monday night. All that remained to be decided was conditions the board could place on the property controlling noise, dust and other issues.
“I agree with all of you,” board member Frank Zuzek told the dozens of vocal residents who turned out to oppose the project. “I live in this community with you. I’m not happy.”
The three-member board has been fighting the request since November 2010, when the Denver-based company originally sought permission to build the station as an “essential service,” to the township.
Board members disagreed with that characterization, Mr. Augustine said, and rejected the application.
Since then, the issue has wended its way through the courts, concluding April 15, when state Commonwealth Court refused to hear an appeal from the township and ordered it to approve the application within 45 days.
MarkWest representatives said 20 percent of their budget for the project is expected to be spent on noise-dampening efforts, including a 35-foot wall encircling the condensate tanks with 8 inches of foam insulation.
Board members said they hoped to control the emissions from a flare at the site that will emit volatile organic compounds and carcinogens, like benzene and formaldehyde.
Compressor stations work by removing fluid and debris from gas and increasing the pressure of gas flow through the pipeline. The material taken from the gas is then burned off through the flare.
Residents living within a quarter of a mile from of the site, including a family who has a child with asthma, said the release of toxic material was what worried them most.
“This is your one time to get it right,” said lawyer Jon Kamin, who represented some of the property owners. “I would ask you not to rush.”
Mr. Kamin gave the board a 6-inch binder full of documents and a list of more than two dozen conditions that could be placed on the project, including that it use electric- — not gas-powered — engines, and that the site be monitored by a third party for air and water quality.
Using electric power could cut down on emissions, but company officials said it wasn’t feasible.
“I’m begging you to consider it,” said alternate board member Anthony Menosky, who compared the project to one in nearby Robinson that uses electric-powered engines. “It’s just right up the road; why can’t we do it here?”
The concern was echoed by Jess Adamsky, the mother of the child with asthma, who asked the company to reconsider.
“We’re not saying don’t come here, we’re saying come here responsibly,” she said.
Paul O’Donnell was the lone resident who spoke in favor of the project.
“This compressor station is a key component to the development of oil and gas in Cecil Township,” he said, reminding the board that nearby municipalities reaped millions in impact fees from drillers while Cecil received just $20,000 last year.
Mandating electric power would be akin to telling the company how to do business, said Robert McHale, company manager of special projects. He suggested board members “think long and hard” about making it a requirement.
Christopher Rimkus, managing counsel for MarkWest, offered to delay a vote until the board’s June 15 meeting to give both sides a chance to determine conditions. The board hoped the offer by the company would waive the 45-day deadline imposed by the court, which is May 30
Mr. Rimkus said MarkWest wasn’t “a company full of evil people,” and that they were trying to be a good neighbor.
“I think that’s being a great neighbor,” Mr. Menosky said.
Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1159.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.